Home Case Index All Cases Income Tax Income Tax + AT Income Tax - 2024 (1) TMI AT This
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
2024 (1) TMI 795 - ITAT CHANDIGARHNature of Income as surrendered during survey proceedings - surrendered amount as "business income" OR "deemed income" i.e income from undisclosed sources - CIT (Appeals) sustained the surrendered amount u/s 68 of credit entry and u/s 69 of excess stock - appellant contended that surrendered amount represents the "business income" as the appellant has no other source of income Whether deeming provisions of Section 68 can be invoked in respect of amount introduced in the capital account of the assessee and found credited during the course of survey in the books of accounts of the assessee? - HELD THAT:- The Survey team had asked a specific question to the assessee during the course of survey to explain the source of capital introduced during the financial year 2018-19 relevant to assessment year 2019-20 and in response, the assessee had stated that he was unable to explain the source of capital introduced during the during the financial year 201819 relevant to assessment year 2019-20, however, in order to buy piece of mind, he voluntarily surrendered the sum - Therefore, during the course of survey, the assessee has failed to offer any explanation regarding the source of such capital introduced in his capital account. Even during the course of assessment and appellate proceeding, we find that no explanation is forthcoming from the assessee. We therefore find that basis material available on record, the credit entry in the capital account of the assessee clearly demonstrate that the receipt of money by the assessee and in absence of any explanation from the assessee explaining the source of such capital introduced, the provisions of section 68 are clearly attracted and we therefore affirm the findings of the ld CIT(A) as far as bringing to tax the amount under section 68 of the Act. Whether the AO has invoked the deeming provisions of section 69 and brought to tax excess stock found during the course of survey which is sustained by the ld CIT(A)? - In the instant case there is no physical distinction between the accounted stock and unaccounted stock. No such physical distinction was found by the Revenue either. We therefore find that the difference in stock so found out by the authorities has no independent identity and is in terms of value terms only and thus part and parcel of entire stock, therefore, it cannot be said that there is an undisclosed asset which existed independently and thus, what is not declared to the department is receipt from business and not any investment as it cannot be co-related with any specific asset and the difference should thus be treated as business income. Thus the income surrendered during the course of survey cannot be brought to tax under the deeming provisions of section 69 of the Act and the same has to be assessed to tax under the head “business income”. In absence of deeming provisions, the question of application of section 115BBE doesn’t arise and normal tax rate shall apply. The AO is thus directed to assess the income under the head “Income from Business/profession” and apply the normal rate of tax.
|