2000 (11) TMI 75 - HC - Income Tax

Summary

Issues:
1. Computation of capital gains on sale of shares including bonus shares.
2. Treatment of bonus shares in relation to shares held prior to January 1, 1954.
3. Application of fair market value as the cost of acquisition under section 55(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961.
4. Judicial interpretation of the value of bonus shares in determining capital gains.

Analysis:
1. The case involved the computation of capital gains on the sale of shares, including bonus shares received by the assessee. The Income-tax Officer did not assign any value to the bonus shares while determining the capital gains. The Tribunal held that the bonus shares should be assigned a value by spreading the cost of acquisition over the original shares and the bonus shares. However, the Tribunal left undisturbed the cost of acquisition for shares purchased after January 1, 1954.

2. The Supreme Court precedent in Shekhawati General Traders Ltd. v. ITO clarified that for shares held prior to January 1, 1954, the subsequent issue of bonus shares should not reduce the fair market value of the original shares. The value of bonus shares received in relation to shares held prior to January 1, 1954, must be determined by spreading the statutory cost over the bonus shares. This principle was applied in the present case to value the bonus shares received by the assessee.

3. The court referred to the case of Escorts Farms (Ramgarh) Ltd. v. CIT, which emphasized that bonus shares should not be considered as having no value, and their value must be determined by spreading the cost of old shares over both old and new shares. The court distinguished this case from Shekhawati General Traders Ltd. by highlighting the different factual scenarios but maintained the principle established in the Shekhawati case regarding the treatment of bonus shares.

4. The court concluded that the value of shares held prior to January 1, 1954, cannot be disturbed if the assessee opted for the fair market value as the cost of acquisition. The bonus shares received, which are related to the shares held prior to January 1, 1954, must be assigned a value by spreading the statutory cost. Similarly, shares acquired after January 1, 1954, should have their cost of acquisition spread over the purchased shares and related bonus shares. The court directed the computation of capital gains based on the correct valuation method provided by the assessee's counsel, resulting in a revised tax liability for the assessee.