TMI Blog1975 (11) TMI 69X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... owed on saree borders in the original assessment was incorrect. The exemption was therefore, sought to be withdrawn by way of revision. The details regarding the taxable turnover as compared in the original assessment and the additions now proposed and made in revision are as under : Asst. yr. Taxable turnover as determined in the original assessment Purchase of saree borders Sale value estimated 1969-70 12,18,786.91 11,832.89 14,790.49 1970-71 14,65,038.13 19,496.99 24,371.09 1971-72 15,17,207.13 31,759.74 33,699.68 1972-73 16,81,018.61 32,162.00 40,203.23 The figures in the last column are under dispute both on merits and on law. The sales relate to saree borders. These have been described by the assessing and the app ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... ting breadthwise, we do not find any difference between any other normal cloth piece. We do not also find any admixture of "sari" i.e. gold lace normally found in expensive Kancheepuram sarees. Even what looks like "golden" lace found in some of the boarders was explained by the representative of the dealer as nothing more than coloured yarn made of artificial fibre. This would be clear from the price itself which is must less than real "zari" lace. All these are either wholly or predominantly cotton or staple fibre. There is no dispute as to the facts. The dispute, however, relates to the classification for these "saree borders". It is the appellant's explanation that the items sold by the appellant would come either under item 4 or under ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... to ready use as such articles. After such transformation the article can no longer retain its previous state of cloth though it is made of cloth. We re unable to appreciate the argument that any workmanship or embroidery made upon a length of cloth should, by reason of some labour or money being spent over the cloth, deprive the cloth of its and existing character. The plain words of the enactment do not permit any limitation upon the meaning of the express term "cloth" by reason of its being subject to any workmanship thereupon after the stage or weaving" Many other High Courts, have followed to same view. For example, Rajasthan High Court considered even "Floor cover carpet" to be falling within the general sense of the word "cloth". The ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... material need not be exclusively of cotton yarn but it may be partly of cotton yarn and partly or staple fibre, rayon, artificial silk or wool" The learned Counsel, therfore, would say that the authorities should have no difficulty in accepting the appellant's contention. He submitted that the original exemption was rightly allowed and that there was absolutely no ground for taking a different view. The learned State Represetnative on the other hand cited the decision of this Tribunal in T.A. 320/61, dt. 22nd Dec., 1961, a decision rendered prior to Kittappa's case. He also cited the decision of the Madras High Court in Abdul Hameed Saheb vs. State of Madras (reported in 16 STC 822) wherein the Madras High Court held that "zari embroidery ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X ..... ose consider by the High Court reported in 16 STC 822. Madras, is misplaced. The learned State Representative relied upon the decisions of Gujarat and other High Courts where the entries are not at all identical. The entry in Gujarat and West Bengal is narrow. There are no words like "all varieties of textiles" and the entry follows Central Excise Law. Even though, the learned counsel would try to get some support from some of these decisions also, we do not, however, consider it proper to take those cases laws for consideration either for or against the appellant. Under the circumstances, we find the 'saree borders' sold by the appellant should be treated as falling under item 4 of Sch. III and exempt the same. In the view of we have taken ..... X X X X Extracts X X X X X X X X Extracts X X X X
|