Tax Management India. Com
Law and Practice  :  Digital eBook
Research is most exciting & rewarding
  TMI - Tax Management India. Com
Follow us:
  Facebook   Twitter   Linkedin   Telegram
VAT - Highlights / Catch Notes

Home Highlights May 2023 Year 2023 This

Binding nature of Tribunal Order - Principle of “consistency” - ...

Case Laws     VAT and Sales Tax

May 3, 2023

Binding nature of Tribunal Order - Principle of “consistency” - Not only the Tribunal but all the Authorities subordinate to it are bound to follow and comply with the law laid down by the Tribunal. This is necessary to maintain judicial discipline and avoid uncertainty in law. The Tribunal may, in appropriate cases, take a view different from the one taken by it earlier if there is change in law or the fact situation in the context whereof the law was declared by it earlier. The Assessing Authorities or the Statutory Appellate Authorities under the GST Act cannot and should not take a view on question of law contrary to the view taken by the Tribunal. - HC

View Source

 


 

You may also like:

  1. Gross violation of CBEC instructions and the precedential value of CESTAT decisions. The Revenue filed an appeal before the first Appellate Authority without specifying...

  2. The subordinate authority is not empowered to supersede the orders passed by the appellate authority and an administrative discipline requires that the subordinate...

  3. Applicability of Advance ruling - The binding nature is to be decided with reference to the nature of decisions by the Advance Ruling Authority. It is not as if that...

  4. Rectification application u/s 254 - Tribunal not followed the decision on the identical facts by the Coordinate Bench which is confirmed by this Court - The Court...

  5. Exemption from turnover - inter-state sale or not - Form-F declaration - false document - consignment sales or not - AO rejected the claim on inter-state movement of...

  6. Foreign Tax Credit (FTC) u/s 90/90A - Judicial precedent - The Bench is of considered opinion that Ld. first Appellate Authority being Subordinate to the Tribunal was...

  7. The law declared by the Hon'ble Supreme Court shall be binding on all Courts within the territory of India and since the Commissioner is not above the Courts therefore...

  8. Validity of remanding the matter to the Assessing Authority - the first appellate authority has adjudicated the controversy on merits and therefore, the tribunal, which...

  9. Stay petition before appellate authority - CBDT circular regarding stay of demand does not seem to bind the appellate authority, though it binds at the lower echelons.

  10. Control of income-tax authorities - U/s 118 of IT ACT 1961 - Specifies the income-tax authority or authorities as subordinate to such other income-tax authority or...

  11. Commissioner failed to follow binding Tribunal precedents on classification of bio-fungicides and bio-insecticides, erroneously believing Supreme Court appeals left...

  12. As long as a judgment of the Tribunal stands, it would bind every Bench of the Tribunal of equal strength and the departmental authorities taking up such an issue - HC

  13. The case concerns benami transactions and the attachment of properties. The Adjudicating Authority initially refused to confirm the attachment order, citing funds...

  14. CESTAT Mumbai analyzed the case involving 'API supari' to determine the rate of duty and the applicability of Advance Ruling u/s 28J of Customs Act, 1962. The tribunal...

  15. Clandestine manufacture and recovery of Central Excise Duty along with interest and penalty - suppression of facts and misrepresentation alleged against petitioner -...

 

Quick Updates:Latest Updates