The respondent authority failed to provide reasons for levying ...

Transfer of goods between own units without sale shouldn't attract interest/penalty. Authorities must give reasons as per CBIC circular & court precedents.

Case Laws GST

July 27, 2024

The respondent authority failed to provide reasons for levying interest and penalty, despite the goods being transferred between the petitioner's establishments, not sold. The court relied on CBIC's circular and previous judgments in Dhabriya Polywood Ltd. and Orson Holdings Company Ltd., which granted benefit of doubt and considered lack of ill-intent, respectively. The impugned orders were quashed and set aside, and the matter was remanded for a fresh de novo order, assigning detailed reasons after hearing the petitioner, considering the cited decisions.

View Source

← Previous Next →

The respondent authority failed to provide reasons for levying ...

Transfer of goods between own units without sale shouldn't attract interest/penalty. Authorities must give reasons as per CBIC circular & court precedents.

Case Laws GST

July 27, 2024

You may also like:

Liability of tax - movement of capital goods from the petitioner’s unit in SEZ to DTA unit - the plea of lease arrangement under which capital goods are transferred from...

Demand of service tax - Supply of tangible goods for use - transfer of right to use goods - deemed sale - The Tribunal observed that, evidently, the Appellant had...

Transfer of CENVAT Credit - closure of Delhi unit & merger with its Baddi unit - Rule 10 of CCR - prima-facie with respect to claim of the appellant or request for...

Transfer of CENVAT Credit to lessee unit - Rule 10 of CCR 2004 - On going through the entire agreement, it is clear that there is consensus ad idem to transfer the...

Levy of GST - sending goods/ raw material/ capital goods from one unit to other - Existing and new unit (situated within the same state) would have same GSTIN - Being...

The High Court considered the levy of VAT on a franchise of a trademark, analyzing whether the transfer of the right to use goods constituted a deemed sale. Citing a...

Inter unit transfer of goods would constitute a sale or not - It is thus evident that unless and until there are two distinct entities, the question of sale may not...

Classification of supply - activity of building and fabricating of Tipper Body and mounting the same by the applicant on the chassis - If the activity of fabrication and...

Transfer of CENVAT Credit - Sale of manufacturing unit alongwith raw material and semi finished goods - It is permitted even to transfer the Cenvat credit to the buyer...

Mis-declaration of quantity and value of goods in SEZ unit - penalty u/ss 112(a) and 114A of Customs Act 1962. Option for reduced 25% penalty u/s 114A to be extended if...

Branch transfers or stock transfers - The stipulations made in the declaration form ‘F’ are nothing but giving particulars of the relevant document in support of branch...

SSI Exemption - two units owned by Husband and wife respectively - If both the units are complete by itself, capable of manufacturing the goods without any help from the...

The case involves the transfer of title of goods from a Free Trade Warehousing Zone (FTWZ) unit to customers in the Domestic Tariff Area (DTA), or multiple transfers...

Cenvat credit for Goods Transport Agency (GTA) service used for transportation of finished goods is recoverable, treating it as rightly availed credit. Transportation...

CENVAT Credit - transfer of unutilized credit, on shifting of factory - Transfer of unutilized credit also denied on the ground that appellants have shifted on inputs...

Quick Updates: