Challenge to non-speaking order of assessment and consequential ...

Non-speaking assessment order passed without considering objections; violated principles of natural justice. Revenue to re-do assessment.

Case Laws GST

October 5, 2024

Challenge to non-speaking order of assessment and consequential rectification order. Order passed without considering objections, violating principles of natural justice. Revenue agreed to re-do assessment. High Court set aside assessment order, treating it as show cause notice. Petitioner to appear before Revenue, submit objections and evidence. Revenue to pass speaking order after hearing petitioner. Rectification petition dismissed as assessment order set aside, rendering it infructuous. Non-application of mind by adjudicating authority warranted setting aside orders and re-adjudication in accordance with law after following due process.

View Source

← Previous Next →

Challenge to non-speaking order of assessment and consequential ...

Non-speaking assessment order passed without considering objections; violated principles of natural justice. Revenue to re-do assessment.

Case Laws GST

October 5, 2024

You may also like:

Violation of principles of natural justice by the authority in passing a non-speaking order without applying its mind to the material on record. It emphasizes that...

The High Court found the order passed by the authority to be violative of principles of natural justice as it was a non-speaking order that failed to address the...

The Assessing Officer failed to pass a detailed speaking order explaining the rationale for enhancing the declared value of aluminum scrap imported by the respondent...

Effect of not passing speaking order by CIT(A) - it was incumbent upon CIT(A) to pass a speaking order after proper appreciation of the facts before her and have to...

Non-speaking order - Once the litigant before the Tribunal placed reliance upon the decision of the a coordinate Bench of the Tribunal, then a speaking order would...

Cancellation of GST registration of the petitioner - non-speaking order - Not only the order is non-speaking, but cryptic in nature and the reason of cancellation not...

Reopening of assessment u/s 147 - Non speaking order disposing of objections against reopening - Disposal of this matter is needed as dealing with the objections to the...

Impugned order by NCLT granting interim injunction against petitioners set aside for being non-speaking, unreasoned, cryptic, laconic without considering triple test for...

Non consideration of objections to the draft assessment order u/s 144 - since the objections were well within time, the action of the AO in proceeding with the final...

Reopening u/s 147 - non disposing objections by AO before proceeding with the assessment by passing a speaking order - The re-assessment cannot be sustained

Reopening of assessment u/s 147 - non disposal of the objections by the AO by passing speaking order - sufficient to quash re-assessment order

Refund - Refund was sanctioned by the lower authority pending the audit objection - The Tribunal ought to have considered the contentions as urged on behalf of the...

The High Court quashed the reassessment order due to procedural defects. The Assessing Officer failed to dispose of the assessee's objections through a speaking order...

Ex-parte order passed by CIT-A - Non speaking order - The exercise of the “right to be heard at the hearing of the appeal” by “the appellant, either in person or by an...

Finalization of provisional assessment - The authorities below have erred in collecting the Duty at ₹ 300/- per M.T., which is clearly illegal and in violation of...

Quick Updates: