In a case concerning disallowance of loss incurred in a plastic ...

Plastic division's loss deduction upheld; Followed accrual accounting & settlement.

Case Laws Income Tax

October 18, 2024

In a case concerning disallowance of loss incurred in a plastic division, the assessee followed the mercantile system of accounting, and contracts were accounted for on an accrual basis. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) dismissed the revenue appeal, holding that tax is levied on real income with aspects of certainty. The High Court upheld the ITAT's decision, considering the Supreme Court's ruling in Commissioner of Income Tax v. Excel Industries Ltd., which emphasized levying tax on real income rather than hypothetical income. The settlement agreement acknowledged the contract's partial disintegration, causing the assessee to lose the right to receive the full transaction value. Accounting Standards (AS) 4 and 9 were considered for contingencies occurring after the balance sheet date. The High Court found no manifest error in the ITAT's judgment favoring the assessee.

View Source

← Previous Next →

In a case concerning disallowance of loss incurred in a plastic ...

Plastic division's loss deduction upheld; Followed accrual accounting & settlement.

Case Laws Income Tax

October 18, 2024

You may also like:

Disallowance of mark to market losses - Nature of loss - allowable business loss or not? - The assessee is consistently following the method of accounting. Therefore,...

Addition u/s 43B - Method of accounting - unpaid statutory dues of service tax, Excise and PF by changing the method of accounting - The assessee followed the exclusive...

Rejection of books of account - Correct method of accounting - following cash system of accounting instead of accrual method of accounting - He has not cared to discuss...

Claim of Refund and Interest on Refund - Unjust enrichment - amount claimed as refund was not charged to the profit and loss account but retained in 'receivables'...

Disallowing foreign exchange loss - claim of exchange fluctuation loss in revenue account by the Assessee in accordance with generally accepted accounting practices and...

This case discusses various issues related to the income tax assessment of a bank. The key points are: Disallowance of expenditure incurred for reservation of seats in...

Criminal proceedings involving allegations of fraudulent activities in an IPO were challenged. The validity hinged on whether a Single Judge or Division Bench should...

Treatment to Forex loss incurred by the assessee on account of derivative transactions as speculative transactions - When the assessee enters into a hedging transaction...

Disallowance of swap contract loss - whether the loss is not real but a notional loss for the reason that there was no actual transaction carried out by the assessee -...

Bid-loss - Claim of business loss - assessee was explaining the principle followed by them, which results in bid loss. What the AO wanted was to give evidence that the...

Accrual of interest expenditure / income - CIT(A) deleted the disallowance u/s 36(1)(iii) - Where there is no certainty of collection, revenue cannot be said to be...

Understatement of income on account of sale of energy - change in method of accounting of sales realization - if action of Ld. A.O and the Ld. CIT(A) in adding on...

Claim of deduction due to loss of Cash in the fire in July 2010 - The entry relating to the loss of cash having been made in the books of account of the assessee only on...

Addition on account of lump-sum lease charges received - lease transaction does not give an absolute ownership or title as it can be cancelled and re-entered - assessee...

The loss arising on account of cancellation of forward contract would also be a business loss and therefore the assessee is entitled to claim the said loss in his books...

Quick Updates: