2007 (10) TMI 401 - HC - Companies Law

Winding up - Powers of Official Liquidator - whether as sale in favour of the appellant had been confirmed and, therefore, the learned Company Judge was wrong in ordering re-advertisement - Held that - There is no doubt that the Official Liquidator is required to adopt a procedure so that the sale of assets of a company in liquidation fetches the maximum price so as not to defeat the process of liquidation which is to satisfy the creditors. The appellant was, concededly, given the option to participate in the fresh bid and also to give a higher bid if it so desired during the proceedings in Company Application No. 358 of 2005 when the property had not been re-advertised, but it chose to remain silent. The process of re-advertisement has clearly fetched much higher price than what was given by the appellant. Having regard to the aforesaid and especially in view of the fact that the appellant had the option to go in for fresh bidding and the property in question has fetched more than twice the amount offered by the appellant, we do not find any infirmity in the impugned order.

Issues:
1. Validity of the order directing re-advertisement of property in liquidation.
2. Consideration of higher bids and interests of the company in liquidation.
3. Official Liquidator's duty to maximize asset sale price.
4. Appellant's refusal to participate in fresh bidding.
5. Justification for remitting the matter back to the Company Judge.

Analysis:

Issue 1: Validity of the order directing re-advertisement of property in liquidation
The appeal challenged an order directing re-advertisement of a property in liquidation with a reserve price of Rs. 2.10 crores. The sale to the appellant was allegedly confirmed earlier, but subsequent higher bids necessitated the re-advertisement. The Court found that the process of re-advertisement resulted in a significantly higher bid of Rs. 3.50 crores by a new respondent, justifying the re-advertisement order.

Issue 2: Consideration of higher bids and interests of the company in liquidation
The Court emphasized that the Official Liquidator must ensure the sale of assets maximizes the price to satisfy creditors. The higher bid of Rs. 3.50 crores by the new respondent, more than double the appellant's bid, was considered in the best interest of the company in liquidation. The appellant had the opportunity to participate in fresh bidding but chose not to, leading to the acceptance of the higher bid.

Issue 3: Official Liquidator's duty to maximize asset sale price
It was acknowledged that the Official Liquidator must follow a procedure to obtain the highest price for assets to prevent the liquidation process from being undermined. The Court noted that the re-advertisement process resulted in a substantially higher bid, demonstrating the effectiveness of the procedure in maximizing the asset's sale price.

Issue 4: Appellant's refusal to participate in fresh bidding
The appellant's refusal to engage in inter se bidding or provide a higher bid during the proceedings indicated a lack of interest in increasing their offer. Despite opportunities to submit a higher bid, the appellant remained silent, leading to the acceptance of the superior bid by the new respondent.

Issue 5: Justification for remitting the matter back to the Company Judge
Due to the Court's order preventing finalization of the bid, the matter was remitted back to the Company Judge for further proceedings. The decision to dismiss the appeal was based on the appellant's failure to participate in fresh bidding and the acceptance of a significantly higher bid in the interest of maximizing the asset's sale price. The Company Judge was directed to proceed in accordance with the law after giving notice to the parties.

This detailed analysis of the judgment highlights the key issues addressed by the High Court in the case involving the sale of assets of a company in liquidation and the considerations taken into account while determining the validity of the re-advertisement order and the acceptance of higher bids.

← Previous Next →