9911796707
|
Home
Issues:
Claim for interest on currency retained by the Department. Analysis: The judgment revolves around an application seeking direction for the payment of interest on a sum of Indian currency held by the Department from 2-12-1988 to 27-10-2005, following the setting aside of the confiscation of the currency in a previous order. The applicant based the claim on Rules 40 and 41 of the CESTAT (Procedure) Rules, 1982, asserting the Tribunal's discretionary power to award interest on money unlawfully withheld by the Department. Upon reviewing the records and arguments from both sides, the Tribunal acknowledged the release of the currency to the applicant after the confiscation was annulled in Final Order No. 1039/2005. The applicant subsequently sought interest on the amount, citing a judgment from the Calcutta High Court regarding the Tribunal's authority to grant interest on belatedly released redemption fines by Customs authorities. However, the Department contended that since the final order had been fully implemented with the currency's release, the claim for interest was not consequential to the order and should not be entertained. The Tribunal, after considering the provisions referenced by the applicant and the submissions of both parties, interpreted Rule 41 as conferring discretionary power to be exercised in the interest of justice, prevention of process abuse, or to give effect to final orders. It noted that the final order was effectively executed upon the currency's release to the applicant and highlighted that the appeal did not originally include a claim for interest on the amount. Consequently, the Tribunal deemed it beyond its authority to entertain the interest claim at that stage under the cited rules, suggesting the applicant pursue legal remedies elsewhere for any valid interest claim. Ultimately, the Tribunal dismissed the application, emphasizing that the discretionary power under Rule 41 did not warrant entertaining the interest claim post-currency release, as the final order had been fulfilled, and no further action was deemed necessary by the Tribunal.
|
