9911796707
|
Home
Issues involved: Misdeclaration of goods, enhancement of value, confiscation of goods, penalty, past imports, demand of duty, adjudication of dispute.
Misdeclaration of goods: The appellants imported goods declared as "VGA CARD SIS 6326 CHIPSET" but Customs authorities found "AGP" markings on the cartons, suspecting misdeclaration. The department proposed to enhance the value of the goods under Rule 5 of the Customs (Valuation) Rules, 1988, and confiscate the goods under Section 111(m) of the Customs Act, along with imposing a penalty under Section 114A. Enhancement of value and confiscation: The Commissioner ordered the enhancement of value of the goods covered under the Bill of Entry, confiscation of goods, and imposition of redemption fines in lieu of confiscation. Additionally, past imports were also held liable for confiscation, with a redemption fine imposed. A demand for duty and penalty was confirmed on the importer. Contestation and appeal: The appellants contested the misdeclaration allegations and the proposed actions on past imports. The appeal argued that AGP CARD is a type of VGA CARD, supported by a certificate and invoices. The Commissioner's decision was challenged as not considering all relevant evidence and not accepting the transaction value agreed upon by the importer and supplier. Adjudication and remand: The Tribunal rejected the actions against past imports based on contemporaneous materials and set aside the demand and confiscation orders. Regarding the goods covered under the Bill of Entry, the Tribunal found the importer's argument plausible based on IT literature and remanded the case for de novo adjudication, emphasizing the importance of the Chartered Engineer's Certificate and the need for a proper examination of the plea. Conclusion: The Tribunal allowed the appeal by way of remand, setting aside the impugned order and directing the Commissioner to re-adjudicate the dispute related to the goods covered under the Bill of Entry dated 1-11-1999, considering all relevant evidence and arguments presented by the importer.
|
