1998 (11) TMI 16 - HC - Income Tax

Summary

Issues:
1. Request for waiver of interest under section 220(2A) of the Income-tax Act, 1961.
2. Consideration of hardship at the time of assessment.
3. Interpretation of statutory conditions for waiver.
4. Relief from genuine hardship versus adding to the wealth of the assessee.

Analysis:

1. The judgment revolves around the assessee's plea for the waiver of interest under section 220(2A) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, covering multiple years. The Commissioner rejected the request, emphasizing that no undue hardship was caused to the assessee due to paying the interest levied.

2. The counsel for the assessee argued that hardship should be assessed at the time of assessment, not at any subsequent point. Citing a precedent from the Madhya Pradesh High Court, it was contended that circumstances prevailing when invoking the Commissioner's jurisdiction should be considered, without drawing an artificial line at any specific point preceding the decision date.

3. The judgment delves into the interpretation of statutory conditions for waiver, highlighting that the purpose is to relieve genuine hardship, not to enhance the assessee's wealth. It is emphasized that waiver can only be granted if the statutory conditions for relief are met, and the burden lies on the applicant to demonstrate the necessity of waiver based on these conditions.

4. The court emphasized that if no hardship exists at the time of seeking relief, it cannot be granted based on past hardships. In this case, as the assessee had already received a substantial sum from property sale, no undue hardship was deemed to be present at the time of the Commissioner's order. Therefore, the judgment upheld the Commissioner's decision to deny the waiver, as there was no hardship requiring relief at the time of assessment.

Overall, the judgment underscores the importance of assessing hardship at the relevant time, interpreting statutory conditions for waiver, and ensuring that relief is granted only in cases of genuine hardship, not to augment the assessee's wealth.