1999 (6) TMI 26 - HC - Income Tax

Summary

Issues:
1. Eligibility of cash assistance under section 80HH.
2. Allowability of interest paid under section 220(2) as a deduction.

Issue 1: Eligibility of Cash Assistance under Section 80HH

The case involved the question of whether cash assistance received from the government for the export of goods is eligible for relief under section 80HH of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The assessee, a domestic company engaged in manufacturing, claimed relief under section 80HH and regarding interest paid under section 220(2). The Income-tax Officer and the Commissioner of Income-tax denied the relief, which led to the matter being brought before the Tribunal. The Tribunal rejected the relief sought by the assessee, prompting the reference to the High Court.

In the argument, the assessee contended that the cash assistance should be considered part of the profit derived from the industrial undertaking and thus eligible under section 80HH. The counsel for the respondent, however, argued that the assistance related only to the export of goods and did not constitute profit or gain derived from the industrial undertaking. Reference was made to the Supreme Court decision emphasizing the interpretation of the term "derived from." The counsel for the assessee highlighted Section 28(iiib) of the Act, which treats cash assistance against exports as business income chargeable to tax. The assessee's position was that the cash assistance was part of the profits and gains of the business and should qualify for relief under section 80HH.

The High Court, considering the Supreme Court's interpretation of "derived from" and the legislative intent behind section 80HH, concluded that the cash assistance given only for export did not qualify as profit or gain derived from the industrial undertaking. The Court noted that there was no nexus with the industrial undertaking in the case of cash assistance for export, as it was only relevant at the time of exporting goods and not related to the working capital for processing. Therefore, the Court upheld the Tribunal's decision, ruling against the assessee's claim for relief under section 80HH.

Issue 2: Allowability of Interest Paid under Section 220(2) as a Deduction

The second question raised in the case concerned the allowance of interest paid under section 220(2) of the Income-tax Act as a deduction. Citing a previous decision, the High Court held that when tax due is based on profits and gains of business or profession, any interest payable for non-payment of such tax should be considered as levied on the basis of those profits or gains and cannot be allowed as a deduction. Therefore, the High Court answered the second question of law in the affirmative, ruling against the assessee's claim for deduction of interest paid under section 220(2).

In conclusion, the High Court affirmed the decisions of the Tribunal on both issues, denying the assessee's claims for relief under section 80HH and the deduction of interest paid under section 220(2). Costs were not awarded in the case.