2011 (7) TMI 55 - HC - VAT and Sales Tax

Sale price - handling charges or service charges for registration of motor cycle - valuation - Held that - The transfer of property in the goods in pursuance of the sale contract takes place against the payment of the price of the goods. Delivery of the goods is effected by the seller to the buyer. The obligation under the law to obtain registration of the motor vehicle is cast upon the buyer. The service of facilitating the registration of the vehicle which is rendered by the seller assessee is to the buyer and in rendering that service, the seller acts as an agent of the buyer. The handling charges which are recovered by the Respondent cannot therefore be regarded as forming part of the consideration paid or payable to the Respondent for the sale. Those charges cannot fall within the extended meaning of the expression sale price , since they do not constitute a sum charged for anything done by the seller in respect of the goods at the time or before the delivery thereof.

Issues Involved:
1. Whether the Maharashtra Sales Tribunal was correct in law in setting aside the tax on the handling charges or service charges for registration of motorcycles with consequential interest levied thereon.
2. Whether the Maharashtra Sales Tax Tribunal was correct in holding that the amount of handling charges or service charges for registration of motorcycles is not part of the 'sale price' within the meaning of section 2(25) of the MVAT Act.

Issue-wise Detailed Analysis:

1. Setting Aside the Tax on Handling Charges or Service Charges:
The appeal by the Revenue contested the Tribunal's decision to set aside the tax on handling charges for motorcycle registration. The Respondent, an authorized dealer of Hero Honda motors, was assessed for handling charges for several financial years. The Tribunal concluded that handling charges did not constitute part of the sale price under Section 2(25) of the MVAT Act, 2002. The Tribunal remanded the proceedings to the Appellate Authority to recompute the sales tax excluding the handling charges. The Revenue argued that handling charges should be included in the sale price, as per the definition in Section 2(25), which includes any sum charged for anything done by the seller in respect of the goods at the time of or before delivery.

2. Definition of 'Sale Price' under Section 2(25) of the MVAT Act:
The Tribunal's decision was based on the interpretation of 'sale price' under Section 2(25) of the MVAT Act, which includes any sum charged for anything done by the seller in respect of the goods at the time of or before delivery, excluding insurance for transit or installation costs. The Respondent argued that handling charges are for post-sale services, as the obligation to register the vehicle lies with the purchaser. The Tribunal found that the sale and delivery of the motorcycle were complete before the registration process, and handling charges were for services rendered after the sale.

Factual and Legal Submissions:
The Respondent provided documents showing that handling charges were separate from the sale price. The sale certificate and gate pass issued to the purchaser confirmed the delivery of the motorcycle. The Appellant argued that under Rule 42 of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989, delivery cannot occur before registration, making handling charges part of the sale price. However, the Tribunal noted that Rule 47 requires registration within seven days of delivery, indicating that delivery can precede registration.

Interpretation of Relevant Statutes and Rules:
The Tribunal and the Court examined the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, and the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989. Section 39 of the Motor Vehicles Act mandates that a vehicle must be registered to be driven, and the obligation to register lies with the owner. Rule 47 of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules requires an application for registration within seven days of delivery. The Tribunal concluded that the handling charges were for post-sale services, not part of the sale price.

Precedents and Judicial Reasoning:
The Court referred to several precedents, including:
- State of Gujarat vs. Jayantilal Bhimji & Sons (1973): Service charges not part of sale price.
- State of Madras v. Srinivasa Timber Depot (1974): Charges for services enabling selection of goods not part of sale price.
- Commissioner of Sales Tax v. Premier Automobiles Ltd. (1985): Service charges for post-delivery benefits not part of sale price.
- State of Karnataka v. Bangalore Soft Drinks Pvt. Ltd. (2000): Freight charges not part of sale price if property in goods passes at the factory.

Conclusion:
The Court upheld the Tribunal's decision, affirming that handling charges for registration are not part of the sale price under Section 2(25) of the MVAT Act. The charges are for services rendered post-sale, and the obligation to register the vehicle lies with the purchaser. The appeal by the Revenue was dismissed, with no order as to costs.

← Previous Next →