1974 (7) TMI 26 - HC - Income Tax

Summary

Issues:
1. Correctness of the penalty order imposed by the Income-tax Officer.
2. Whether the failure to furnish the return was without reasonable excuse.
3. Basis for calculation of the penalty imposed by the Income-tax Officer.

Detailed Analysis:
Issue 1: The High Court was tasked with determining the correctness of the penalty order imposed by the Income-tax Officer. The Tribunal found that the Officer had not indicated the period of delay or the basis for the calculation of the penalty, leading to a lack of judicial exercise of power. However, the Court held that the penalty order could not be considered illegal as the period of default in filing the return was evident from the records.

Issue 2: The Court examined whether the failure to furnish the return was without reasonable excuse. The assessee claimed that the delay was due to the illness and subsequent demise of the accountant responsible for filing the return. Despite this submission, the Income-tax Officer and higher authorities did not accept it as a reasonable cause under section 271(1)(a) of the Income-tax Act.

Issue 3: The crucial question was the basis for the calculation of the penalty imposed by the Income-tax Officer. The Tribunal contended that the penalty was illegal because the Officer did not explicitly record the basis for the calculation. However, the Court clarified that under section 271(1)(a)(i), the Officer's discretion to levy a penalty is preserved, and the statutory provision itself sets the basis and quantum of the penalty. Therefore, the Officer was not required to explicitly state the basis for the calculation, as it was evident from the statute and the facts on record.

The Court concluded that while the Income-tax Officer's penalty order was not flawed, any reduction in the tax payable by the assessee for the relevant assessment year would lead to a corresponding reduction in the penalty amount. The Court answered the reference question in the negative, subject to the consideration of any reduction in tax payable affecting the penalty leviable under section 271(1)(a)(i) of the Income-tax Act, 1961.