9911796707
|
Home
Issues:
Interpretation of section 194A - Applicability to specific trust Analysis: The judgment deals with appeals by the assessee against the order of CIT(A) related to assessment years 1983-84 to 1990-91 and 1991-92. The main issue raised was the applicability of section 194A to the case of the assessee. The assessee, a trust created by Shri Rambhai S. Patel, had 25 beneficiaries in Schedule I and 23 beneficiaries in Schedule II. The income distribution among the beneficiaries was specified in the Trust Deed. The Assessing Officer held that the trust did not fall under the category of "individual" or "HUF" as per section 194A, making it liable to deduct income tax on interest payments. The CIT(A) confirmed this decision, leading to the appeal. The counsel for the assessee argued that since the beneficiaries were individuals or HUFs and were directly assessed, the provisions of section 194A should not apply to the trust. The counsel relied on various legal precedents to support this argument. However, the Departmental Representative contended that the trust, as a "person" under the Act, was obligated to deduct income tax under section 194A, emphasizing the definition of "person" in the Act. The Tribunal analyzed the legal position regarding the assessment of trustees of a specific private trust. Referring to Supreme Court decisions, the Tribunal established that trustees of a private specific trust are assessable in the same manner and to the same extent as the beneficiaries they represent. It was clarified that trustees would be assessable as "individual" or "HUF" if they represent beneficiaries assessed in those categories. In this case, since the trustees represented individuals and HUFs, they were to be assessed in the status of individuals and HUFs, not as A.O.P. or B.O.I. The Tribunal concluded that the provisions of section 194A did not apply to the trustees of the specific trust, as the beneficiaries had already been assessed in their respective categories. In light of the analysis, the appeals by the assessee were allowed, indicating that the provisions of section 194A regarding the liability to deduct income tax on interest payments were not applicable to the trustees of the specific trust.
|
