1984 (3) TMI 118 - AT - Income Tax

Summary

Issues:
Assessment of interest income accrued but not received by the assessee.

Analysis:
The only issue in this appeal was whether the assessee should be assessed for interest of Rs. 4,000 due from a firm to whom the assessee had advanced a loan. The Income Tax Officer (ITO) found that the assessee was maintaining accounts on a mercantile basis and held that the interest had accrued and should be included in the assessment. The Appellate Assistant Commissioner (AAC) upheld this decision, stating that the amount due had not become a bad debt and should be included in the assessment since the accounts were maintained on an accrual basis.

The assessee appealed against this decision, arguing that the income should be assessed under 'other sources' and not as 'business income'. The assessee's counsel contended that no income had accrued during the year as the debtor had not acknowledged any indebtedness. Additionally, the assessee had not credited any interest in the books of account, indicating a change in the method of accounting to cash. The department, however, argued that there was no evidence of a change in the accounting method and that the debtor's financial status did not support the claim that no income had accrued.

The tribunal considered the facts and noted that the assessee had not changed the method of accounting for other items, thereby rejecting the argument of a switch to cash accounting. The tribunal emphasized that the determination of whether income had accrued should be based on commercial and business realities rather than the accounting method. The tribunal highlighted that the debtor's financial difficulties, as indicated in a letter from the assessee's chartered accountants, suggested that it was unlikely for the assessee to receive any dues. Consequently, the tribunal concluded that the assessee was not in receipt of income by way of interest, and the interest addition was deleted.

In conclusion, the tribunal accepted the assessee's appeal, ruling that the interest addition should be removed based on the commercial and business realities of the situation, indicating that the assessee was unlikely to receive the interest income due to the debtor's financial instability.