Full value of consideration for transfer of share other than quoted share for computation of Capital Gain - Clause 79 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025 vs Section 50CA of the Income-tax Act, 1961

Clause 79 Special provision for full value of consideration for transfer of share other than quoted share.

Income Tax Bill, 2025

Introduction

Clause 79 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025, and Section 50CA of the Income-tax Act, 1961, both address the valuation of consideration received from the transfer of unquoted shares for the purpose of computing capital gains. These statutory provisions aim to ensure that income from capital gains is calculated based on the fair market value of shares, rather than potentially understated transaction values. This commentary provides a comprehensive analysis of these provisions, exploring their objectives, implications, and the nuances involved in their application.

Objective and Purpose

Both Clause 79 and Section 50CA are designed to prevent tax evasion through the undervaluation of shares in transactions involving unquoted shares. The legislative intent is to ensure that the capital gains tax is levied on a fair market value basis, thus preventing the understatement of income and tax liabilities. Historically, the transfer of unquoted shares posed challenges for tax authorities due to the potential for manipulation in determining the transaction value, as opposed to quoted shares whose market value is readily available through stock exchanges.

Detailed Analysis of Clause 79 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025

1. Clause 79(1):

The first subsection of Clause 79 stipulates that if the consideration received from the transfer of an unquoted share is less than its fair market value, the fair market value shall be deemed the full consideration for computing capital gains. This provision ensures that the transferor cannot avoid tax by undervaluing the transaction. The fair market value is to be determined in a prescribed manner, which likely involves valuation guidelines issued by the tax authorities.

2. Clause 79(2):

This subsection provides an exemption from the application of Clause 79(1) for certain classes of persons and under specific conditions, as prescribed. This flexibility allows the government to exempt certain transactions or entities from this provision, possibly to encourage specific economic activities or to accommodate genuine cases where the fair market value does not reflect the transaction's economic reality.

3. Clause 79(3):

The definition of "quoted share" is provided, clarifying that it refers to shares regularly quoted on a recognized stock exchange. This distinction is crucial as the provision specifically targets unquoted shares, where the potential for undervaluation is significant.

Detailed Analysis of Section 50CA of the Income-tax Act, 1961

1. Section 50CA Main Provision:

Similar to Clause 79(1), Section 50CA mandates that when the consideration for transferring an unquoted share is less than its fair market value, the fair market value is deemed the consideration for capital gains purposes. This ensures consistency in the tax treatment of such transactions, aligning the taxable amount with the economic value of the asset transferred.

2. Proviso to Section 50CA:

The proviso introduced through subsequent amendments allows for exemptions similar to those in Clause 79(2). This amendment reflects an understanding of the need for flexibility in tax legislation, accommodating genuine cases where the strict application of the provision may lead to unjust outcomes.

3. Explanation in Section 50CA:

The explanation provides clarity on what constitutes a "quoted share," aligning with the definition in Clause 79(3). This consistency ensures that taxpayers and tax authorities have a common understanding of the terms used in these provisions.

Comparative Analysis

When comparing Clause 79 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025, with Section 50CA of the Income-tax Act, 1961, several similarities and differences emerge:

1. Similarities:

• Both provisions address the valuation of unquoted shares for capital gains tax purposes.
• They mandate the use of fair market value as the deemed consideration if the transaction value is lower.
• Exemptions are provided for specific classes of persons or conditions, offering flexibility in application.
• The definition of "quoted share" is consistent across both provisions.

2. Differences:

• Clause 79 is part of a proposed bill and may reflect updated legislative intent or adjustments to address evolving economic contexts.
• The specific classes of persons and conditions for exemption may differ between the two provisions, reflecting changes in policy priorities or economic conditions.
• The procedural aspects for determining fair market value, while not explicitly detailed in the provisions, may differ based on evolving valuation methodologies or regulatory guidelines.

Practical Implications

1. Impact on Taxpayers:

• Taxpayers involved in the transfer of unquoted shares must ensure compliance with these provisions by accurately determining and reporting the fair market value of shares.
• The potential for exemptions provides relief in genuine cases, but taxpayers must be aware of the specific conditions and classes of persons eligible for such exemptions.

2. Compliance Requirements:

• Accurate valuation of unquoted shares is critical, necessitating the involvement of qualified valuers or adherence to prescribed valuation guidelines.
• Documentation and record-keeping become essential to substantiate the fair market value and support any claims for exemptions.

3. Regulatory Implications:

• Tax authorities must ensure robust mechanisms for monitoring compliance and addressing valuation disputes.
• The provisions necessitate clear guidelines and procedures for determining fair market value, requiring collaboration between tax authorities, valuers, and stakeholders.

Conclusion

Clause 79 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025, and Section 50CA of the Income-tax Act, 1961, play a crucial role in ensuring that capital gains tax is levied on a fair value basis for unquoted share transactions. By addressing potential undervaluation and providing for exemptions, these provisions balance the need for revenue protection with flexibility for genuine cases. As economic contexts and valuation practices evolve, these provisions may require further refinement to address emerging challenges and ensure effective implementation.

 

---

Full Text:

Clause 79 Special provision for full value of consideration for transfer of share other than quoted share.

 

Dated: 15-3-2025