It is well settled in law that a decision of the court is only ...

January 27, 2021

Case Laws VAT and Sales Tax HC

It is well settled in law that a decision of the court is only an authority for what it decides and not what can logically be deduced therefrom. It cannot be quoted for a proposition that may seem to follow logically from it and such a mode of reasoning assumes that law is necessarily a logical code, whereas it must be acknowledged that law is not always logical. It is equally well settled legal position, that court should not place reliance on a decision without discussing as to how the factual situation fits in with the fact situation of the decision, on which reliance is placed - the revisional authority could not have concluded in the fact situation of the case that the tribunal has failed to decide or has decided erroneously any question of law. - HC

View Source

← Previous Next →

It is well settled in law that a decision of the court is only ...

January 27, 2021

Case Laws VAT and Sales Tax HC

You may also like:

A decision, it is well settled, is an authority for what it decides and not what can logically be deduced therefrom. The distinction between a dicta and obiter is well...

Attachment of property of petitioner - merely because of the wrong quoting of the provision, the order impugned before the Writ Court cannot be successfully assailed by...

Jurisdiction of Additional CIT - The Standing Counsel should understand that this Tribunal is not to decide the mercy petition but has to decide the issue before it in...

Modification in the Bill of entry - assessee used a wrong expression "re-assessment of Bill of Entries" and did not quote the provision of law - This cannot be taken...

Rejection of books of accounts - assessee had failed to segregate expenses of the contract business from other nine trucks - there is no presumption in law attaching...

Classification of goods - chlorinated paraffin - It is a settled law that any clarification with regard to any Act will always have retrospective effect for the reason...

If a person pays commission to the non-resident no TDS deduced from the payment - AT

Question of law or facts - on the facts and circumstances of the instant case, as the plea of limitation turns on facts and as it is clearly not a pristine question of...

Filling of ITR quoting wrong PAN - this complex issue is liable to be examined by the Income Tax Commissioner / respondent No.1 considering the practical problem which...

Validity of Tribunal's order - Tribunal decided issue on merit instead of deciding the stay application - The Tribunal should not act as per its whims and fancies,...

100% EOU - cut flowers cleared to domestic market - The SCN is issued in terms of the B-17 Bond executed by them with the customs authorities is not time barred - terms...

Validity of the draft assessment order issued in the name of non-existent entity - TP adjustment - arm’s-length price u/s 92CA - once the draft assessment order and...

Maintainability of appeal - time limitation - No doubt there was no application seeking Condonation of delay was filed by the appellant as has been acknowledged by ld....

Change of jurisdiction u/s 127 - As in the present case, the Assessing Officer rejected the objection regarding the jurisdiction and referred the matter to the PCIT to...

Reopening of assessment u/s 147 - It is clear that the primary facts necessary for assessment were also disclosed. It is settled law that the Assessing Officer is not...

Quick Updates: