Power of the Commissioner (Appeals) - The Commissioner (Appeals) ...

Commissioner (Appeals) must stick to issues raised in appeals; improper directions exceed appeal scope, royalty issue settled.

December 16, 2023

Case Laws Customs AT

Power of the Commissioner (Appeals) - The Commissioner (Appeals) cannot examine and pronounce upon any issue beyond the factum of the appeal. It is imperative that all actions of public functionaries be guided by reason and not by whim or caprice - it is found that the directions given in the impugned order is improper and travels beyond the appeal. The issue of royalty not being related to the impugned goods during the said period has become final as no cross objections have been filed on the issue by Revenue. - AT

View Source

← Previous Next →

Power of the Commissioner (Appeals) - The Commissioner (Appeals) ...

Commissioner (Appeals) must stick to issues raised in appeals; improper directions exceed appeal scope, royalty issue settled.

December 16, 2023

Case Laws Customs AT

You may also like:

The appellant filed bills of entry claiming exemption under Notification No. 46/2011-Cus, which was denied during re-assessment. The Commissioner (Appeals) rectified...

The ITAT Gauhati Bench jurisdiction issue was raised concerning an appeal filed under improper jurisdiction. The assessee's address was consistently in Kolkata, with no...

Jurisdiction of Commissioner (Appeals) to issue fresh Show Cause Noice (SCN) or to raise demand on new ground - The power to issue a notice is specifically provided for...

Power of Commissioner (appeals) - appeal was considered on merit and directions were issued to the lower authority for re-assessing the Bills of Entry with consequential...

Violation of principles of natural justice - denial of cross-examination - pre-mature appeal - The Tribunal ruled that the issue of denial of cross-examination could be...

Assessment u/s 144A - Power of JCIT to issue directions in certain cases - Directions to be exercised by the Joint Commissioner under Section 144(A) is merely intended...

Right of department to file any appeal or cross-objections before the Commissioner (Appeals) against Refund order - the Department could neither have filed an appeal...

CESTAT held that appellant was entitled to benefit under N/N. 94/96-Cus for imported goods that were initially exported and returned. While the adjudicating authority...

The assessee raised an issue before the CIT(Appeals) which was not adjudicated. The assessee can raise this unadjudicated issue before the Tribunal by way of an...

CIT(Appeals) dismissed assessee's appeal for non-prosecution despite assessee being afforded multiple opportunities to participate. However, CIT(Appeals) failed to...

Condonation of delay in filing appeal before Commissioner (Appeals) - Initially the appellant was advised to file a representation before the Chief Commissioner against...

Jurisdiction - competency of the Additional Commissioner to adjudicate and finalize the assessment - CESTAT held that, the Commissioner (Appeals) has also considered...

ENVAT Credit - credit availed prior taking the registration - the invoices of pre-registration phase shall also be considered for availment of Cenvat credit by the...

Jurisdiction - scope of SCN - The Appellate Authority be it the Commissioner (Appeals) or the Tribunal is not empowered to issue directions which traverse beyond show...

Introduction of the authority of Joint Commissioner (Appeals) - In order to reduce burden or bottleneck of small cases with small amount of disputes and demand from...

Quick Updates: