Principles of natural justice violated due to vague summary ...

Improper notice & order for ITC reversal sans reasoned adjudication; remanded for fresh consideration.

Case Laws GST

September 11, 2024

Principles of natural justice violated due to vague summary notice merely citing risk of excess ITC availed by petitioner on account of GSTR mismatch. Order u/s 73 of CGST Act set aside as proper officer failed to consider detailed replies with supporting documents filed by petitioner, merely stating they were unsatisfactory without application of mind. Reference to audit observation erroneous as no audit conducted u/s 65. Impugned order quashed, show cause notice remitted to proper officer for re-adjudication. Petition disposed of by remand.

View Source

← Previous Next →

Principles of natural justice violated due to vague summary ...

Improper notice & order for ITC reversal sans reasoned adjudication; remanded for fresh consideration.

Case Laws GST

September 11, 2024

You may also like:

Although the Tribunal is undoubtedly entitled to remand a matter for fresh consideration, the same cannot be at its whim and fancy or mere ispi dixit but a conclusion...

Validity of remand of matter to the AA to pass fresh order - It is settled principles of law that every decision is to be supported by reasons inasmuch as reasoning is...

Input Tax Credit - commission paid to the foreign agent - High Court has observed some discrepancy in the order of tribunal - The High Court ought to have then remanded...

The High Court found a violation of principles of natural justice due to a non-speaking order by the adjudicating authority, which ignored the petitioner's replies and...

Section 50C's multiplicative rate applicability was challenged. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal affirmed the Commissioner's order applying a factor of "1" to the...

The Tribunal's order exonerating assessees from customs duty and penalty for undervaluation during import displayed inconsistency. It selectively relied on statements of...

Power of commissioner (appeals) to remand back the case - There are no piece of evidence to take a contrary view to the finding of the first appellate authority as to...

Power of Remand - The order passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) remanding back the matter for fresh adjudication is set aside and the case is remanded back to the...

Validity of the Order-in-Original - Adjudication of show cause notice - The petitioner argued that they were not given a fair opportunity to present their case and...

Levy of interest u/s 50(3) - Wrong availment of Input of Tax Credit and reversal thereof - The court noted that the issue of levying interest under Section 50(3) of the...

Disallowance u/s 14A - disallowance of administrative expenditure to arrive at average total asset for computing disallowance as per formula prescribed by Rule 8D on the...

Reasoned Order - Exemption of Duty – Reasons are a soul of any judicial order and good and proper reasoning makes its body strong - Court remands the matter back to Tribunal - HC

HC considered levy of tax, interest, and penalty on CMWSSB for supplying purified water. HC found issues with adjudication: 1) Misinterpretation of purified water...

The High Court found that the respondents failed to properly consider the petitioner's contentions regarding the retrospective cancellation of GST registration of its...

Petitioner challenged demand for GST on unbilled revenue, explaining position. Adjudicating Authority rejected explanation without reasons, violating natural justice...

Quick Updates: