Principles of natural justice violated due to vague summary ...

Improper notice & order for ITC reversal sans reasoned adjudication; remanded for fresh consideration.

September 11, 2024

Case Laws GST HC

Principles of natural justice violated due to vague summary notice merely citing risk of excess ITC availed by petitioner on account of GSTR mismatch. Order u/s 73 of CGST Act set aside as proper officer failed to consider detailed replies with supporting documents filed by petitioner, merely stating they were unsatisfactory without application of mind. Reference to audit observation erroneous as no audit conducted u/s 65. Impugned order quashed, show cause notice remitted to proper officer for re-adjudication. Petition disposed of by remand.

View Source

← Previous Next →

Principles of natural justice violated due to vague summary ...

Improper notice & order for ITC reversal sans reasoned adjudication; remanded for fresh consideration.

September 11, 2024

Case Laws GST HC

You may also like:

The appellants challenged the order contravening FEMA for unauthorized direct investment outside India in an overseas JV not engaged in bona fide business activity. They...

CESTAT upheld Commissioner (Appeals)'s decision to remand case back to Adjudicating Authority for fresh adjudication. The original order was challenged for violating...

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) has adjudicated on various issues concerning deductions u/ss 80IA(4), 14A, and 35D. Regarding Section 80IA(4) deduction, the...

HC set aside adjudication order u/s 74(9) of WBGST/CGST Act 2017 and remanded for fresh consideration. The adjudicating authority failed to address key submissions...

Although the Tribunal is undoubtedly entitled to remand a matter for fresh consideration, the same cannot be at its whim and fancy or mere ispi dixit but a conclusion...

Validity of remand of matter to the AA to pass fresh order - It is settled principles of law that every decision is to be supported by reasons inasmuch as reasoning is...

The HC held that the Commissioner's order under Section 263 of the IT Act constituted an open remand, not a closed remand, as it set aside the assessment order and...

Input Tax Credit - commission paid to the foreign agent - High Court has observed some discrepancy in the order of tribunal - The High Court ought to have then remanded...

The main order rejecting condonation of delay lacks reasons, violating principles of natural justice. It is a well-settled legal position that an affidavit-in-reply...

The High Court set aside the adjudication order blocking the Petitioner's credit ledger due to lack of personal hearing and violation of principles of natural justice....

HC set aside GST demand order dated 21.11.2024 for non-consideration of binding departmental circulars (No.200/12/2023-GST and No.236/30/2024-GST). Matter remanded to...

Tribunal held Adjudicating Authority's order cryptic, failing to examine appellants' defense regarding legitimate procurement and supply of gold as business transaction....

The CESTAT allowed the appeal by way of remand for de novo adjudication. It held that although sufficient opportunities were granted to the appellant, including personal...

Reasoned Order - Exemption of Duty – Reasons are a soul of any judicial order and good and proper reasoning makes its body strong - Court remands the matter back to Tribunal - HC

The HC quashed the order cancelling petitioner's GST registration for failure to file returns for six months. The Court found that authorities failed to consider the...

Quick Updates: