The High Court dismissed the petition filed by an informer ...

Court Dismisses Petition on Alleged Luxury Car Duty Evasion; Emphasizes Need for Evidence and Technical Expertise.

October 22, 2024

Case Laws Customs HC

The High Court dismissed the petition filed by an informer seeking directions against private respondents (importers of luxury cars) and statutory authorities (Customs, DRI) for alleged undervaluation and duty evasion. The court held that complex matters involving technical expertise on import valuation, pricing, and duty cannot be adjudicated in writ jurisdiction. The statutory authorities had already investigated based on the informer's information and found no violation by the importers. Mere suspicion without substantiating collusion or mala fides cannot warrant directions against authorities or importers. The informer cannot misuse his status for a witch-hunt against importers. Substantial investigation had already occurred, and the proceedings cannot continue merely on the informer's insistence. The court cannot issue directions regarding future imports in writ jurisdiction.

View Source

← Previous Next →

The High Court dismissed the petition filed by an informer ...

Court Dismisses Petition on Alleged Luxury Car Duty Evasion; Emphasizes Need for Evidence and Technical Expertise.

October 22, 2024

Case Laws Customs HC

You may also like:

Assessment of trust - purchase of luxury car i.e. Audi Car - purchase of for the benefit of trustess only or not for charitable use? - Merely because the vehicle happens...

Clandestine removal - evasion of duty - clearance of branded Khaini - burden to prove on Revenue - Ultimately, the High court concurred with the majority view of the...

The High Court analyzed evidence in a case involving dishonored cheques. The court emphasized the need to rebut the presumption u/s 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act....

Reopening of assessment u/s 147 or u/s 153C - validity of proceedings - The High Court emphasized the need for the Assessing Officer to properly apply relevant...

Seizure of tobacco and loss of the same due to file - Liability of central excise department - Whether the Trial Court has committed error of facts and law in passing...

Import of high end luxury cars from various foreign suppliers by mis-declaring as new - Undervaluation of goods - Appellant is a subsequent purchase of the car - the...

The Rajasthan High Court considered a case involving the detention of goods due to an expired e-way bill, raising concerns about tax evasion. Citing a judgment from the...

The High Court addressed the issue of interim compensation u/s 143A of the NI Act, 1881 for dishonored cheques. It emphasized the need for a prima facie evaluation of...

The Delhi High Court upheld the order quashing of the disciplinary proceedings against the Regional Director (NR) of ROC, emphasizing the distinction between executive...

The legality and validity of the termination of arbitral proceedings u/s 32(2)(c) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 - The Supreme Court found no evidence of...

Levy of Penalty u/s 129(3) of the Central Goods and Service Tax Act, 2017 - Errors in e-way bills - The Court emphasized that minor typographical errors in e-way bills,...

Grant of temporary bail on medical grounds - twin provisions of Section 212 (6) (ii) of the Companies Act, 2013 satisfied or not - Despite the prosecution's objection to...

Seeking grant of bail - creation and operation of 294 fake firms and has evaded a tax - The court noted the serious nature of economic offences and the substantial loss...

A legal challenge was raised regarding the requirement to pay the Social Welfare Surcharge (SWS) on imported goods when the basic customs and additional duty were...

Clandestine Removal - reliability of statements - sufficiency of evidence or not - In a serious case such as evasion of duty by fraud, the degree of appreciation of...

Quick Updates: