Tax Management India. Com
Law and Practice  :  Digital eBook
Research is most exciting & rewarding
  TMI - Tax Management India. Com
Follow us:
  Facebook   Twitter   Linkedin   Telegram
Customs - Highlights / Catch Notes

Home Highlights November 2024 Year 2024 This

The central issue revolves around the maintainability of a ...


Customs duty dispute: Revenue's single appeal against 93 Bills of Entry deemed non-maintainable.

Case Laws     Customs

November 6, 2024

The central issue revolves around the maintainability of a single appeal filed by the Revenue against multiple Bills of Entry. As per Rule 6(A) of the CESTAT Procedure Rules, 1982, when separate orders-in-original are passed for each Bill of Entry, the appellant is required to file separate appeals corresponding to each order. However, in this case, the Commissioner (Appeals) disposed of appeals concerning 93 Bills of Entry through a common order-in-appeal. Consequently, the Revenue is obligated to file 93 separate appeals challenging each Bill of Entry, as each assessment order constitutes a distinct cause of action. This interpretation aligns with the National Litigation Policy's stance that monetary thresholds apply to individual appeals rather than the aggregate amount. The Tribunal, concurring with prior judicial precedents, held the single appeal filed by the Revenue as non-maintainable and directed the filing of 93 separate appeals if advised.

View Source

 


 

You may also like:

  1. Seeking release of the consignment - sale of goods after import - seeking cancellation of the previous bill of entry filed with the customs, and permit the Petitioner to...

  2. The law prevalent as on the date of the import of the vessel in the case on hand would only be applicable and that merely because the bill of entry was not filed at the...

  3. Waiver of late fees - Bill of Entry got purged before payment of duty through IGST - filing of fresh Bill of entry due to system error - The imposition of late fee...

  4. Rule 6(A) requires filing separate appeals for each order-in-original. In a case involving multiple Bills of Entry, if a common order-in-appeal disposed of appeals...

  5. Legislative Competence to Levy of stamp duty on ‘Bill of Entry’ (BoE) and on Delivery Orders (DO) - goods imported in Maharashtra - seek refund paid on stamp duty - The...

  6. CENVAT Credit - valid duty paying documents or not - Transfer Memos - Endorsed Bill of Entry - It is to be noted that the bill of entry is one of the approved documents...

  7. CENVAT credit - duty paying invoices - endorsed Bill of Entry - in some of the Bills of Entry, the endorsement was signed by the Customs authority - Credit cannot be denied - AT

  8. Relevant date for payment of Customs Duty - The respondent had submitted all the four Bills of Entry with the relevant documents on 05.07.2019 before 5 PM and the...

  9. Refund claim - rejection of refund on the ground that no appeal was filed - In the present case, the Revenue admittedly, amended the Bills of Entry by re-assessing the...

  10. One appeal filed by the Revenue against 7 Bills of Entry is not maintainable. As per Rule 6(A) of the CESTAT Procedure Rules, 1982, when the Commissioner (Appeals)...

  11. Levy of penalty - late filing to bill of entry - since the Customs Official did not clear the goods under exemption, the appellant had no option but to file bill of...

  12. Validity of final/reassessment order of Bill of Entry - ex parte final assessment of the Bill of Entry - the respondent No.4 has made final assessment/re-assessment of...

  13. Refund of amounts collected from the Petitioners as stamp duty on Bills of Entry filed for the goods imported - Legality and validity of collecting the stamp duty on the...

  14. Retrospective exemption granted from payment of any customs duty on import of "Rough diamonds (industrial or non-industrial)" for the period 1.7.2017 to 1.2.2022....

  15. Amendment to Bill of entry - Declaration of one painting (instead of two) in the Bill of Entry - Confiscation and penalty - No infirmity in denying the amendment of...

 

Quick Updates:Latest Updates