The HC dismissed the writ petition challenging an assessment ...

Assessment Order Challenge Fails: Court Rules Limitation Questions Require Full Trial, DIN Issue Subject to Supreme Court Stay

March 19, 2025

Case Laws Income Tax HC

The HC dismissed the writ petition challenging an assessment order on grounds of limitation and absence of Document Identification Number (DIN). The Court held that questions of limitation involve mixed questions of fact and law that cannot be summarily determined on affidavits alone. Regarding the DIN issue, the Court noted that the Supreme Court had stayed a similar Calcutta HC decision in Tata Medical Center Trust. Following Bank of Baroda v. Farooq Ali Khan, the Court emphasized that statutory tribunals are constituted to determine questions of law and fact, and High Courts should not substitute themselves as decision-making authorities when exercising judicial review powers. The petition was deemed not maintainable as alternative and efficacious statutory remedies remained available to the petitioner.

View Source

← Previous Next →

The HC dismissed the writ petition challenging an assessment ...

Assessment Order Challenge Fails: Court Rules Limitation Questions Require Full Trial, DIN Issue Subject to Supreme Court Stay

March 19, 2025

Case Laws Income Tax HC

You may also like:

The HC declined to entertain a writ petition challenging an assessment order on grounds of limitation and absence of Digital Identification Number (DIN). The court held...

HC rejected discharge application in money laundering case involving Resolution Professional (RP). Court affirmed RPs qualify as public servants under Prevention of...

HC set aside GST assessment proceedings due to absence of Document Identification Number (DIN). Following established precedents and CBIC Circular No.128/47/2019-GST...

The HC held that the trial for offences under PMLA can continue independently even during the pendency of trial for the predicate offence. Since the nature of money...

Deactivation of DINs of petitioner - Since such DIN is allocated under Section 154 of the 2013 Act, and there is no provision in the Act for the deactivation of the DIN...

HC ruled that assessment order lacking Document Identification Number (DIN) is invalid and non-est, following Supreme Court precedent in Pradeep Goyal case. The court...

Validity of Assessment u/s 153A - non-generation of DIN - approval u/s. 153D of the Act is akin to the approval u/s. 151 of the Act, wherein, we find sanction/approval...

Validity of assessment order u/s 143(3) r.w.s 263 - no intimation of DIN for the impugned order - The case of the assessee is that the communication, namely the...

Validity of assessment u/s 153A - Document Identification Number (DIN) - the assessment order when considered establish that DIN was not generated prior to uploading the...

Validity of assessment Order framed on Non quoting the mandatory document identification number (‘DIN’) - AO communicated the DIN after the expiry of 15 days - AO...

HC granted bail in a money laundering case after 3 years and 4 months of pre-trial detention. The prosecution relied on co-accused confessional statements under PMLA...

There is a huge pendency of suits in the Trial Courts in the State of Maharashtra. If the members of the Bar do not cooperate with the Trial Courts, it will be very...

Law for trial of the cross cases - Raid - In the present controversy, two different criminal appeals were being heard and decided against two different judgments based...

100% EOU - Extended period of limitation - escapement of assessment u/s 14 of the Customs Act, 1962 - The question of limitation is a mixed question of fact and law. It...

Seizure of tobacco and loss of the same due to file - Liability of central excise department - Whether the Trial Court has committed error of facts and law in passing...

Quick Updates: