1980 (12) TMI 171 - HC - VAT and Sales Tax

Summary

Issues:
1. Entitlement to split restaurant sales into charges for services and price for sale of goods.
2. Entitlement to split turnover for special receptions and meetings.
3. Justification of excluding receipts from special events from sales tax.

Analysis:
The judgment by the Delhi High Court pertains to the entitlement of a company to split restaurant sales, turnover for special events, and the exemption of receipts from special events from sales tax. The questions arose from sales made by a hotel in Delhi, where the company claimed that sales included elements beyond food, such as entertainment and decorations, not subject to sales tax. The Financial Commissioner had ruled on different aspects, including exempting receipts from special events and excluding a portion of sales from tax for receptions. The company argued that these issues were covered by a Supreme Court judgment regarding the distinction between the sale of food and service of food in a restaurant.

The Supreme Court's unanimous judgment held that serving food in a restaurant is not a taxable sale under the Sales Tax Act, whether charged as a whole or separately. The review petition further clarified that the liability to sales tax depends on the nature of the transaction, emphasizing the distinction between selling food and providing a service. The court highlighted that if food is served in a restaurant without the option for customers to take away unconsumed portions, it constitutes a service, not a sale. Both judgments emphasized that food served in a restaurant is a service to meet customer demand, not a sale of food.

Consequently, the High Court declined to answer the first question on splitting restaurant sales, as the entire amount, including charges for food and services, is not taxable. Similarly, for the second question on consolidated charges at events, the entire amount for food and services is excluded from taxable turnover if no food is taken away by customers. Regarding the third question on receipts from special events, the court held that such amounts are exempt from sales tax. Only sales where customers take away food are chargeable to tax, as per the Supreme Court's ruling. The parties were left to bear their own costs, and the reference was answered accordingly.