2002 (8) TMI 805 - HC - Central Excise

Summary

Issues:
1. Excess excise duty payment on motor vehicles.
2. Refund claim rejection and statutory remedies exhaustion.
3. Contestation of suit based on statutory remedies and res judicata.
4. Decree by the trial court and entitlement to recovery of excess excise duty.
5. Legal interpretation of the suit's maintainability under the Central Excises & Salt Act.

Analysis:

1. The plaintiff-respondent, a Public Limited Company engaged in manufacturing motor vehicles, paid excess excise duty due to a mistake in assessing the duty based on an incorrect price list. The plaintiff sought a refund of Rs. 56,526.03 paid in excess towards excise duty on 46 motor vehicles.

2. The plaintiff filed a refund claim with the Assistant Collector of Central Excise after the defendants acknowledged the excess payment. However, the claim was rejected, and subsequent statutory appeals were deemed time-barred. The plaintiff then filed a suit alleging mis-conception of facts and law in the rejection of the refund claim.

3. The defendants contended that the suit was not maintainable as statutory remedies were not exhausted, and the orders of the Assistant Collector and the Appellate authority were final and binding. They argued that the suit was barred by the principle of res judicata as the issue was already adjudicated upon.

4. The trial court decreed in favor of the plaintiff, acknowledging the excess excise duty payment made in error. It found no evidence of the plaintiff's habit of making excess/short payments and ruled the suit as a simple claim for recovery of money due to a mistake in excise duty payment.

5. The High Court upheld the trial court's decision, emphasizing that the plaintiff was entitled to recover the excess amount paid in excise duty by mistake. It noted the absence of statutory provisions for recovery of excise duty paid in excess by mistake and deemed the refund application as seeking equitable relief. The court determined that the suit was maintainable and not premature under the Central Excises & Salt Act.