1992 (5) TMI 13 - HC - Income Tax

Summary

Issues:
1. Justification of setting aside the Income-tax Officer's order and directing refund of interest.
2. Justification of the conclusion that proceedings under section 154 could not be initiated against the assessee.
3. Determination of whether interest could be charged under section 215 or section 217(1A).
4. Correctness of canceling the order rectifying the mistake apparent from the records by the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal.

Analysis:

The High Court of PATNA addressed a reference under section 256(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, involving various questions of law. The case pertained to the assessment year 1974-75, where the assessee, a limited company, paid advance tax but failed to pay tax as per the estimate filed under section 212(3A) of the Act. The Income-tax Officer assessed the total income and directed the payment of interest for late filing and penal interest under section 217(1A). However, discrepancies arose regarding the demand notice issued and the subsequent order under section 154, leading to an appeal before the Tribunal.

In response to question No. (3), the court analyzed sections 212(3A), 215, and 217(1A) of the Act. It was emphasized that interest under section 217(1A) is levied only if the assessee fails to send the income estimate as required by section 212(3A). The court clarified that if the estimate is filed but the advance tax is not paid, interest under section 215 applies. Referring to a Supreme Court precedent, the court interpreted the word "paid" in section 215 to include cases where tax "ought to have been paid," ensuring fairness and equality.

Regarding question No. (2), the court found it academic due to the conclusion that no interest was chargeable under section 217(1A). Consequently, questions No. (1) and (4) were answered in favor of the assessee, as they were consequential to the resolution of question No. (3). The judgment concluded without any order as to costs and directed the transmission of a copy to the Assistant Registrar of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Patna Bench, as per section 260 of the Act.

The judgment was delivered by G. C. BHARUKA J., with agreement from S. K. CHATTOPADHYAYA J., ensuring a comprehensive analysis of the legal issues raised in the reference under the Income-tax Act, 1961.