1987 (11) TMI 26 - HC - Income Tax

Summary

Issues Involved:
The judgment involves the interpretation of provisions under the Interest-tax Act, 1974 regarding the taxability of amounts charged for delayed payment of bills and the deductibility of rediscounting charges paid to the Industrial Development Bank of India.

Interpretation of Amounts Charged for Delayed Payment of Bills:
The Tribunal considered whether the amounts charged by the assessee for delayed payment of bills constitute "interest on loans and advances" under the Interest-tax Act. The Tribunal noted that the assessee treated these amounts as interest in its books of account and that the agreements referred to the constituents as borrowers required to pay interest for delayed payments. However, the court emphasized that the mere accounting treatment or nomenclature does not determine the true nature of the transaction. The court held that unless the delayed payment charges are proven to be "interest on loans and advances," they are not taxable under the Act. The right to charge for delayed payments arose from the Negotiable Instruments Act, not from loans or advances, making the amounts not exigible to tax as interest.

Deductibility of Rediscounting Charges:
Regarding the rediscounting charges paid to the Industrial Development Bank of India, the Tribunal relied on a previous decision and found that these charges were shared as part of a joint venture under the Bills Rediscounting Scheme. The court agreed with this view, stating that the charges were not deductible under section 6 of the Interest-tax Act. As the Industrial Development Bank of India had an overriding title in the rediscounting process, the charges paid by the assessee were not taxable under the Act.

Conclusion:
The court answered the question referred by the assessee in the negative, stating that the delayed payment charges were not taxable as interest on loans and advances. On the question referred by the Revenue, reframed by the court, the answer was affirmative, indicating that the rediscounting charges paid to the Industrial Development Bank of India were not exigible to tax under the Interest-tax Act. Each party was directed to bear their own costs in the reference.