1985 (8) TMI 13 - HC - Income Tax

Summary

Issues:
- Interpretation of section 261 of the Income-tax Act regarding the issuance of a certificate for appeal to the Supreme Court.
- Whether a certificate for appeal can be restricted to specific questions only.
- Consideration of substantial questions of law for the grant of a certificate.
- Application for a certificate under section 261 in light of subsequent Supreme Court decisions.
- Criteria for determining a "fit case" for the grant of a certificate for appeal to the Supreme Court.

Analysis:
The judgment by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh involves a detailed analysis of the interpretation of section 261 of the Income-tax Act in the context of issuing a certificate for appeal to the Supreme Court. The court deliberated on whether a certificate could be limited to specific questions or if it should relate to the judgment as a whole. The case involved multiple questions referred by the Tribunal, with some answered in favor of the Revenue and others in favor of the assessee. The court considered the retrospective effect of an amended rule, the applicability of section 80J, and the computation of relief under various provisions of the Act.

The court also examined the necessity of substantial questions of law for the grant of a certificate under section 261. It discussed the implications of a Supreme Court decision on the vires of a rule, emphasizing the importance of rectifying judgments in light of subsequent legal developments. The judgment highlighted the significance of unresolved questions affecting a large number of assessees, especially in the context of conflicting views among different High Courts.

Furthermore, the court analyzed the language and intent of section 261, emphasizing that the grant of a certificate is based on the overall case before the High Court and not individual questions. The judgment clarified that once a certificate is granted, there are no restrictions on the scope of the appeal or the jurisdiction of the appellate court. The court concluded that the case met the criteria for a "fit case" for the grant of a certificate under section 261, allowing for an appeal to the Supreme Court. No costs were awarded in this decision.