9911796707
|
Home
Issues:
Assessment of gain from land acquisition - Individual vs. Partnership Analysis: The judgment by the High Court of Delhi involved a dispute regarding the assessment of a gain resulting from the acquisition of land between an individual and a partnership firm. The case revolved around determining whether the gain should be assessed in the hands of the individual or the firm that acquired the land. The firm, initially consisting of six partners, purchased the land in question and later dissolved, with the individual becoming the sole proprietor before joining a new firm with four partners. The key issue was to ascertain the rightful recipient of the gain amounting to Rs. 95,935 following the land acquisition. The court deliberated on the significance of the date of the award in determining ownership rights and tax liability. It was established that the date of the award was crucial, with ownership being transferred after the compensation amount was determined and possession of the land taken. The court referred to the Land Acquisition Act, highlighting the procedural steps involved in land acquisition, including the determination of compensation, making an award, and taking possession of the land. The court emphasized that the compensation amount is the consideration for the transfer of ownership to the government, and the rightful recipient of the compensation should be taxed accordingly. In citing the case of Raja Harish Chandra Raj Singh v. Deputy Land Acquisition Officer, the court emphasized that the date of the award was deemed to be the date of its announcement, not the date of signing, aligning with the nature of rights emanating from the award. Consequently, the court concluded that the partnership firm, which was in existence at the time of the award announcement, was entitled to receive the compensation amount. As the firm had already been assessed, the court ruled in favor of the assessee, directing that the compensation should be payable to the firm. The judgment favored the assessee, leaving the parties to bear their own costs.
|
