1984 (7) TMI 115 - AT - Income Tax

Summary

Issues:
1. Whether the shares received by the assessee by surrendering convertible bonds give rise to capital gains.

Analysis:
The judgment dealt with the issue of whether the conversion of bonds into equity shares would result in capital gains for the assessee. The assessee held 35 bonds issued by a company, which were convertible into equity shares. The assessee exercised this option and received cash and equity shares. The Income Tax Officer (ITO) contended that the conversion gave rise to capital gains and taxed the amount accordingly. The primary dispute was whether capital gains should be levied at all. The assessee argued that there was no transfer involved in the conversion, as there was no sale or exchange, and the asset ceased to exist. The Tribunal, however, held that the conversion of bonds into equity shares constituted a transfer within the meaning of the Income Tax Act. The Tribunal emphasized that the right to convert bonds into shares was voluntary and led to the extinguishment of the assessee's rights in the bonds, satisfying the conditions of a transfer as per the Act.

The Tribunal rejected the assessee's argument that the conversion did not involve a transfer, emphasizing that the conversion transaction could not be split into separate parts. The Tribunal highlighted that the conditions for the definition of 'transfer' under the Income Tax Act were met, as the conversion resulted in the extinguishment of the assessee's rights in the bonds. The Tribunal referenced a previous decision by the Gujarat High Court, which supported the view that extinguishment of rights did not require the asset to continue to exist post-transfer. Additionally, the Tribunal distinguished the case from scenarios involving the issuance of right shares or shares in amalgamation, stating that the creation of new rights and obligations upon exercising the conversion option differentiated this case. The Tribunal ultimately upheld the levy of capital gains on the conversion of bonds into equity shares, dismissing the assessee's appeal.

In conclusion, the judgment clarified that the conversion of bonds into equity shares triggered capital gains for the assessee, as it constituted a transfer under the Income Tax Act. The voluntary nature of the conversion and the extinguishment of the assessee's rights in the bonds were key factors in determining the taxability of the transaction. The Tribunal's decision aligned with previous legal interpretations and established principles regarding the treatment of such conversions for tax purposes.