9911796707
|
Home
Issues:
1. Classification of imported machine under Customs Tariff Heading 84.45/48 or 84.59. 2. Determining whether the machine is a swaging machine or a fitting tool. 3. Interpretation of technical definitions and descriptions related to swaging process. 4. Analysis of the functionality and purpose of the imported hydraulic swaging press. 5. Comparison of the machine's operation with the characteristics of a swaging machine. Analysis: 1. The case involves the classification of an imported machine by M/s. Soldez Industries under Customs Tariff Heading 84.45/48 or 84.59. The dispute arises as the Custom House assessed the machine under 84.59, while the appellants claim it should be classified as a swaging machine under 84.45. 2. The main contention is whether the machine in question is a swaging machine or a fitting tool. The appellants argue that the machine functions as a swaging machine during the process of mounting a metallic sleeve on a braided hose, resulting in a reduction in the diameter of the sleeve. However, the department argues that it is merely a tool for fitting a metal sleeve to a hose, not a swaging machine. 3. The judgment delves into technical definitions of swaging from various sources, emphasizing the process of reducing diameter through forging, squeezing, or hammering. The definitions highlight that swaging involves tapering a rod or tube, which aligns with the appellants' argument that their machine performs swaging by reducing the diameter of the metal sleeve. 4. The analysis focuses on the functionality of the hydraulic swaging press imported by Soldez Industries. It is established that the primary purpose of the machine is to fit and bond the metal end sleeve to the hose securely, rather than solely reducing the diameter of the sleeve. This distinction is crucial in determining whether the machine qualifies as a swaging machine. 5. The judgment compares the operation of the imported machine with the characteristics of a swaging machine, emphasizing that swaging is a metal forming process aimed at changing the shape of metals. The machine's function of fitting a metal sleeve to a hose is deemed as a sleeve fitting process rather than a swaging process, as it does not primarily involve changing the shape of the metal. In conclusion, the appellate tribunal ruled that the hydraulic swaging press imported by Soldez Industries is not classified as a swaging machine under Customs Tariff Heading 84.45/48. The judgment highlights the distinction between metal forming processes and fitting tools, ultimately determining the classification of the imported machine based on its primary function and operation.
|
