ATA CARNET

[YAGAY andSUN]

'Admission Temporary/Temporary Admission’.

ATA Carnet is an International Customs Document that permit duty free and tax free temporary imports of goods during its validity period.  ‘ATA’ means ‘Admission Temporary/Temporary Admission’.

The "ATA" acronym stands for:

A: Admission

T: Temporary

A: Admission

The ATA Carnet is issued by authorized chambers of commerce in the country of origin, and it is typically required to be presented at customs when entering or leaving a country.

ATA Carnet can be used to take out or bring in India the followings:

1. Samples for export promotion or display in exhibitions or;
2. Professional Equipment (e.g. Tools, Musical Instruments, Sports Items, Photography Equipment, Surgical Equipment, Theatrical Goods etc.) by Travelling Professionals.

Total Eighty-One (81) countries are covered under ATA Carnet Chain. These covers USA, UK, China, Singapore, European Union/Countries, India etc.

FICCI, New Delhi is Guaranteeing association for ATA Carnet in India.  Application has to be made to FICCI, New Delhi [www.ficci.org] with security in Form of Bank Guarantee, prescribed application fee along with Proforma Invoice and letter from the Organizer of the Event.

Virtually all goods can be included on a Carnet. Rules and regulations vary from country to country. You are advised to communicate directly with respective customs authorities prior to your travels.

For the customs, the use of the ATA Carnet entails less administrative work and increased customs safety since the payment of import duties and taxes is guaranteed by the Guaranteeing Association affiliated to the ATA guarantee chain in the territory of temporary admission. The guarantee is automatic and the customs need not check its validity for each carnet.

In addition, the system does not affect revenue of the nation since the goods covered by the ATA Carnets are intended for re-exportation and not at all for sale in the country of temporary admission. The system is "self-policing" in that, should the Carnet holder fail to re-export the goods within the period of validity of the Carnet, duties become payable.

The ATA Carnet is valid for one year and can be used for multiple trips to various countries. It acts as a guarantee to customs authorities that the goods will be re-exported before the document expires, ensuring compliance with regulations and avoiding import duties.

Trityque/Carnet De Passage – Trityque/Carnet De Passage is a travel document issued by approval Automobile Associations for temporary importation of private motor vehicle in India duty free by the tourist.  The vehicle must be taken out of India with 6 months. [Notification No. 296/76-Cus].

ATA CARNET - Compliance requirements and restrictions

The ATA Carnet is a valuable tool for the temporary importation of goods, but there are important compliance requirements and restrictions that users must adhere to in order to avoid penalties, fines, or even confiscation of the goods. Here’s a breakdown of the key compliance points and restrictions:

Compliance Requirements:

1. Proper Documentation:
   • Ensure that the ATA Carnet is correctly filled out and reflects all the items being temporarily imported.
   • The goods listed on the carnet must match the physical goods being transported. Any discrepancies may cause delays or penalties.
2. Validity Period:
   • The ATA Carnet is valid for one year. It cannot be used beyond this time frame, and the goods must be re-exported within the period.
   • If you need more time, an extension or a new ATA Carnet will be required.
3. Customs Stamps:
   • Every time the goods are imported or exported, the carnet must be stamped by customs at both entry and exit points. This is essential to prove that the goods were temporarily admitted and then exported.
4. Re-exportation:
   • The primary condition for using an ATA Carnet is that the goods must be re-exported. This means that the goods must leave the country within the timeframe specified (usually one year).
   • Failure to re-export the goods can result in customs duties and taxes being imposed.
5. Authorized Usage:
   • The ATA Carnet should only be used for the purposes for which it was issued (e.g., commercial samples, exhibition items, professional equipment). Using the carnet for different purposes could violate customs laws.
6. Goods Under the Carnet:
   • The carnet can only cover goods that are temporary in nature. The goods cannot be for permanent importation or sale in the country.
7. Multiple Entries and Exits:
   • An ATA Carnet can be used for multiple trips within the one-year validity period. Each time you enter and exit a country, the carnet will be validated by customs.

Restrictions:

1. Countries Accepting ATA Carnet:
   • Not all countries are part of the ATA Carnet system. It is important to check whether the destination country accepts ATA Carnets.
   • Generally, ATA Carnets are recognized in over 80 countries, but some regions (e.g., certain countries in Africa or South America) may not be included.
2. Prohibited Goods:
   • Some goods are excluded from being covered by the ATA Carnet. These can include:
     • Goods intended for sale
     • Goods that might be subject to high import restrictions (e.g., firearms, plants, animals)
     • Certain perishable goods
     • Alcohol and tobacco in some countries
3. Damaged or Lost Carnet:
   • If the ATA Carnet is lost or damaged during the journey, it must be reported immediately to the relevant authorities and the issuing chamber of commerce. A replacement carnet may be issued, but this can involve additional paperwork and fees.
4. Customs Enforcement and Fines:
   • Non-compliance with the terms of the ATA Carnet may result in significant fines, penalties, or confiscation of goods.
   • Goods not exported before the carnet's expiration will be subject to customs duties and taxes as though they were imported permanently.
5. Incorrect Value Declaration:
   • The value of goods must be declared accurately. Misrepresentation of the value, even if accidental, may lead to customs penalties.
6. Transit or Storage Restrictions:
   • Certain countries or regions may have specific restrictions regarding the transit or temporary storage of goods under ATA Carnet. It’s important to understand the regulations in each country you are traveling to.
7. Third-Party Handling:
   • The ATA Carnet must be used by the carnet holder (the person or organization listed on the document) or an authorized representative. If the goods are handed over to a third party for handling or customs clearance, you need to ensure that they follow the appropriate procedures.

Summary of Key Points to Remember:

• The goods must be for temporary use only and must be re-exported.
• The carnet must be properly completed and stamped by customs at each border crossing.
• Certain goods are excluded from ATA Carnet coverage (e.g., alcohol, permanent imports).
• Failure to comply with the conditions of the ATA Carnet can result in customs duties, taxes, and fines.
• Countries accepting the ATA Carnet should be checked before travel to ensure it’s valid.

By following the rules and understanding the restrictions, you can use the ATA Carnet to simplify temporary imports and avoid complications at customs.

***

(The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances).

 

Legal issues or principles commonly discussed in ATA Carnet cases

The ATA Carnet is a widely used international trade document, but there is limited public information or well-known case law regarding its enforcement or specific disputes in common law jurisdictions. However, case law concerning the ATA Carnet generally falls under the categories of customs regulations, temporary importation, and international trade. While specific decisions may be cited in various countries' legal systems, detailed, published case law with citations related to ATA Carnets is sparse, as these matters are typically handled through administrative or customs procedures rather than high-profile court cases.

That said, here are a few examples of legal issues or principles commonly discussed in ATA Carnet cases, along with hypothetical references to show what such cases might look like:

1. Misuse of ATA Carnet:

Hypothetical Case:

• Case Name: ABC Electronics Ltd v. Customs Authority
• Jurisdiction: United Kingdom, Customs Tribunal
• Citation: [2018] UKCT 75
• Summary:
  ABC Electronics Ltd had imported specialized equipment into the UK using an ATA Carnet for a trade fair. However, the goods were later found to have been sold instead of being re-exported, breaching the terms of the ATA Carnet. Customs authorities demanded customs duties and taxes for the importation of the goods.
• Ruling:
  The tribunal held that the ATA Carnet had been misused, and as the goods were not re-exported, customs duties were due. The company was ordered to pay a fine along with back duties based on the market value of the goods. The tribunal emphasized the importance of adhering to the rules governing temporary imports under the ATA Carnet.

2. Late Re-exportation:

Hypothetical Case:

• Case Name: XYZ Exhibitions Ltd v. The Customs Authority
• Jurisdiction: United States, Federal Court of Appeals
• Citation: 2008 US App. LEXIS 12345
• Summary:
  XYZ Exhibitions Ltd used an ATA Carnet to temporarily import items for an exhibition in New York. However, due to unforeseen logistical delays, the goods were not re-exported within the required period. Customs imposed a substantial fine and back taxes, citing a violation of the temporary importation rules.
• Ruling:
  The Court ruled in favour of the customs authority, confirming that goods covered by an ATA Carnet must be re-exported within one year. However, the court granted a reduction in the fine, given the circumstances of the delay and the company's history of compliance.

3. Incorrect Declaration on ATA Carnet:

Hypothetical Case:

• Case Name: Global Instruments Ltd v. Customs Union
• Jurisdiction: European Court of Justice
• Citation: ECJ Case C-455/11
• Summary:
  Global Instruments Ltd used an ATA Carnet to temporarily import medical devices for a demonstration in the EU. The company, however, misdeclared the value of the equipment, leading customs authorities to assess additional duties. The company argued the misstatement was clerical and unintentional.
• Ruling:
  The European Court of Justice ruled that even if the misdeclaration was unintentional, the company had violated the customs regulations. The Court upheld the assessment of the duties but allowed the company to correct the declaration, with a warning against future mistakes.

4. Lost or Damaged ATA Carnet:

Hypothetical Case:

• Case Name: International Trade Co. v. US Customs
• Jurisdiction: United States District Court
• Citation: 2005 US Dist. LEXIS 7890
• Summary:
  International Trade Co. lost an ATA Carnet while transporting goods for a trade show in the United States. Upon arrival, the company sought to clear customs with a duplicate carnet but faced a delay and potential fines.
• Ruling:
  The Court held that customs had the discretion to accept a duplicate ATA Carnet if a formal report of the loss was filed with both the issuing chamber and customs authorities. The case was resolved without penalties, as the court found that the company had acted in good faith and had filed the necessary documentation.

5. Non-Recognition of ATA Carnet in Non-Signatory Countries:

Hypothetical Case:

• Case Name: TechnoTrade Ltd v. Border Customs Authority
• Jurisdiction: Australia, Federal Court
• Citation: 2014 FCA 342
• Summary:
  TechnoTrade Ltd imported items under an ATA Carnet, but the country of temporary importation was not a signatory to the ATA Carnet system. The Australian Customs Authorities refused to accept the ATA Carnet as a valid import document.
• Ruling:
  The Federal Court ruled that Australia was not obligated to accept an ATA Carnet from a non-signatory country. The court reaffirmed that the ATA Carnet system only applies in countries that are part of the international agreement and upheld the customs duties on the goods as they were treated as permanent imports.

General Observations:

1. Penalties for Non-Compliance: In cases where the terms of the ATA Carnet are violated, penalties may include fines, confiscation of goods, and retroactive duties.
2. Discretion of Customs Authorities: Many rulings highlight the discretion of customs authorities in accepting ATA Carnets or in assessing penalties, especially in cases of clerical error, loss of documentation, or delays.
3. Correction of Errors: Some cases involve the possibility of correcting errors on an ATA Carnet, provided they are identified early and the necessary steps are taken to notify the relevant authorities.
4. Cross-Border Recognition: While ATA Carnets are designed for international use, their recognition is based on participating countries, which may lead to legal disputes in non-signatory jurisdictions.

Conclusion:

Specific published case law with direct citations for ATA Carnets remains relatively rare in public legal databases because most disputes are handled through administrative channels or under customs regulations. For detailed citations, it's best to look into legal databases such as LexisNexis, Westlaw, or regional customs rulings for more precise examples. However, the examples above illustrate the types of legal issues companies and individuals might encounter when using ATA Carnets and the likely judicial outcomes in these types of cases.