The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 introduces several provisions to safeguard consumer rights, focusing on product liability and unfair trade practices, both of which are essential to the modern consumer protection framework.
1. Product Liability under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019
Product Liability refers to the legal responsibility of a manufacturer, seller, or service provider for a product or service that is defective or unsafe, causing harm to consumers. The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 introduces product liability as a key provision aimed at holding businesses accountable for defective goods or deficient services that cause harm.
Key Provisions on Product Liability
- Definition:
- Section 2(34) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 defines "product" as any article, commodity, or service that is produced, manufactured, or provided for use by consumers.
- Product liability is the responsibility of the manufacturer, service provider, or seller for the harm caused by a defective product or deficient service.
- Scope of Product Liability:
- Product liability covers any defect in the product or service, including:
- Manufacturing defects.
- Design defects.
- Defects due to inadequate warnings or instructions.
- Deficient service due to improper performance of the service or its quality.
- Liability of Manufacturer/Service Provider:
- A manufacturer or service provider is held liable for a defective product or deficient service if it:
- Causes harm or injury to the consumer.
- The defect in the product or deficiency in the service is a result of the manufacturer’s or service provider’s negligence or failure to ensure the quality of the product/service.
- The defect or deficiency can be proven to have caused physical injury, death, or damage to the property of the consumer.
- Types of Product Liability Claims:
- Defective Product: If a product has defects that cause damage to a consumer, the manufacturer or seller can be held liable.
- Defective Service: If a service rendered is not as per agreed standards, or if it is deficient and causes harm, the service provider will be liable.
- Strict Liability: This refers to liability without fault. If a product is defectively designed or manufactured and causes harm, the manufacturer or seller may be liable, regardless of whether they were negligent.
- Negligence-based Liability: If the manufacturer or service provider was negligent in ensuring product safety or service quality, they may be held liable for harm.
- Defenses Against Product Liability Claims:
- Misuse or Alteration of the Product: If the product was misused or altered by the consumer and this led to the harm, the manufacturer or seller may not be held liable.
- Lack of Knowledge of Defect: If the manufacturer can prove that they were not aware of the defect, or it was impossible to discover the defect at the time of sale or delivery, they might avoid liability.
- Claims for Product Liability:
- Consumers can file claims before the District Consumer Forum, State Consumer Commission, or the National Consumer Commission, depending on the value of the claim.
- Claims can be made for compensation for physical injury, loss, or damage caused by the defective product or deficient service.
2. Unfair Trade Practices under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019
Unfair trade practices refer to any deceptive, fraudulent, or misleading business practice that harms consumers by preventing them from making informed decisions or by exploiting their lack of knowledge.
Key Provisions on Unfair Trade Practices
- Definition of Unfair Trade Practices:
- Section 2(47) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 defines unfair trade practices as a broad range of deceptive, fraudulent, or misleading activities by businesses. These include:
- False or misleading advertisements about products or services.
- Bait advertising: Promising something at an attractive price but not delivering on it.
- Misrepresentation: Making false claims or statements regarding the quality, price, or features of a product.
- Dishonest advertising: Making false or misleading representations to influence consumers' choices.
- Examples of Unfair Trade Practices:
- False Advertising: A company advertises a product claiming it has qualities or features it doesn’t have (e.g., claiming a product is "free" but hiding charges).
- Bait and Switch: Advertising a product at an exceptionally low price but having no intention to sell it at that price. Instead, the consumer is pressured into purchasing more expensive alternatives.
- Misleading Labeling: Selling products with labels that mislead the consumer regarding the quality, quantity, or origin of the product.
- Exaggerated Claims: Making exaggerated or unsubstantiated claims regarding the effectiveness or benefits of a product.
- Prohibition of Unfair Trade Practices:
- Section 2(47) makes it clear that any trade practice that is deceptive or fraudulent will be considered unfair, and businesses indulging in such practices may face penalties.
- The Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) is empowered to take action against businesses indulging in unfair trade practices. This includes issuing cease and desist orders, imposing penalties, and initiating proceedings against the offender.
- Penalties for Unfair Trade Practices:
- The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 provides strict penalties for businesses found guilty of unfair trade practices. This includes:
- Imposition of fines: A fine can be imposed on businesses for misleading advertisements or deceptive marketing.
- Compensation to Consumers: Consumers who have been harmed by unfair trade practices can seek compensation from the business responsible.
- Imprisonment: In cases of severe violations, the offender may face imprisonment for up to 2 years, extendable to 5 years for subsequent offenses.
- Penalty for False Advertisement: A fine of up to ₹10 lakh can be imposed for the first offense, and up to ₹50 lakh for subsequent offenses.
- Role of the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA):
- The CCPA is empowered to take action against misleading advertisements, deceptive practices, and false claims, including the following:
- Investigating complaints of unfair trade practices and taking corrective actions.
- Prohibiting misleading advertisements and initiating penalties.
- Filing class action suits to protect consumers collectively.
- Consumers’ Rights Against Unfair Trade Practices:
- Consumers have the right to seek redressal if they are affected by unfair trade practices. They can file complaints with consumer forums or approach the CCPA.
- They are entitled to compensation, including reimbursement for any damages incurred due to the deceptive practices.
Difference Between Unfair Trade Practices and Product Liability:
|
Aspect
|
Product Liability
|
Unfair Trade Practices
|
|
Definition
|
Legal responsibility of manufacturers, service providers, and sellers for defective products or deficient services causing harm.
|
Deceptive, misleading, or fraudulent business practices that mislead or harm consumers.
|
|
Scope
|
Focuses on defective products or services causing injury or damage.
|
Covers deceptive advertising, misleading labeling, fraud, and other dishonest practices.
|
|
Example
|
A defective product causes injury to a consumer.
|
Misleading advertisement about a product’s features.
|
|
Liability
|
Manufacturer or seller is liable for harm caused by defective products or services.
|
Business can be penalized for misleading consumers through deceptive practices.
|
|
Claims
|
Consumers can claim compensation for injury or loss caused by defective products.
|
Consumers can file complaints for being misled by false advertising or fraudulent claims.
|
Conclusion: The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 strengthens the legal framework to protect consumers against product defects and unfair trade practices. By introducing specific provisions on product liability, businesses are held accountable for defects or deficiencies in the goods or services they offer. Moreover, the Act recognizes and penalizes unfair trade practices like false advertising and misleading claims, ensuring that consumers are not exploited by deceptive business practices.
Through these provisions, the Act aims to make the consumer market safer, more transparent, and more equitable for consumers in India.
9911796707
