Duty Drawback vs. Advance Authorization: Detailed Information, Pros and Cons, and Comparison Analysis.
Both Duty Drawback and Advance Authorization are schemes offered by the Government of India to promote exports by helping exporters reduce their costs. However, these schemes differ in their mechanisms, eligibility, and benefits. Let’s dive into the details:
1. Duty Drawback Scheme
The Duty Drawback scheme allows exporters to claim a refund of customs duties, central excise duties, and service tax paid on inputs and raw materials used in the manufacture of exported goods.
Key Features:
- Refund of import duties on raw materials, packaging materials, and components used in the production of exported goods.
- The exporter receives a refund of duties already paid at the time of importation.
- Available for both manufacturers and merchants.
- Exporters must comply with the required documentation and procedures, and the goods must be exported within a specified time frame.
- The scheme applies to both direct and indirect exports.
Eligibility:
- The goods must be exported outside the country.
- The exporter must be registered with the Customs department.
- Goods must not have been sold domestically or diverted.
Types of Duty Drawback:
- All Industry Rates (AIR): Prescribed rates for certain categories of goods.
- Brand Rate: In cases where the AIR is not applicable, exporters can apply for a brand rate based on their specific case.
2. Advance Authorization Scheme
The Advance Authorization scheme allows exporters to import inputs and raw materials at zero customs duty, provided these materials are used to manufacture goods that will be exported.
Key Features:
- Duty-free imports of inputs that are used in the production of export goods.
- The exporter is required to fulfill the export obligation within a specified period (usually 12 to 18 months).
- The inputs can include raw materials, consumables, and packaging materials.
- The scheme is available to both manufacturers and merchant exporters.
- A minimum export obligation is set based on the quantity of inputs authorized.
Eligibility:
- The exporter must be engaged in the manufacturing of export goods.
- Export obligation must be fulfilled within the prescribed time period.
- The value-added product must be exported in a specified time frame (12-18 months).
- No export obligation for status holders (those recognized as export-oriented businesses with a good export track record).
Types of Advance Authorization:
- Normal Advance Authorization: For standard exporters.
- Advance Authorization for Annual Requirement: For exporters who require raw materials over a longer period.
Pros and Cons of Each Scheme
Duty Drawback Scheme
Pros:
- Refund of Taxes: Exporters get a refund of customs duties already paid.
- Cash Flow Benefit: Exporters don’t have to bear the cost of duties and taxes.
- Simple Process: The process is less complex and faster than Advance Authorization.
- No Export Obligation: There's no need to fulfil any export obligations or quotas once the goods are exported.
- Eligibility for All Exporters: Available to both manufacturers and traders (merchants).
Cons:
- Limited Coverage: It is only applicable to customs duties and excise duties; it doesn’t cover all types of indirect taxes (like VAT or sales tax).
- Refund Process: Exporters might experience delays in the refund process, and it requires detailed documentation.
- No Duty-Free Imports: The exporter still needs to pay customs duties when importing materials, which increases the initial cost.
Advance Authorization Scheme
Pros:
- Duty-Free Imports: Exporters can import raw materials and components without paying customs duties.
- Lower Production Costs: Importing raw materials duty-free reduces production costs, increasing profitability.
- Increased Competitiveness: The exporter can price their products more competitively in the international market.
- Flexibility: The scheme provides flexibility for exporters to choose inputs and decide on the export volume.
Cons:
- Export Obligation: Exporters must fulfil export obligations within a set time frame, which can be challenging for new or small businesses.
- Complex Process: The application and compliance process can be bureaucratic and cumbersome, involving a lot of paperwork and documentation.
- Time Constraints: Exporters must meet stringent deadlines, and failure to meet these obligations could result in penalties.
- Not Available to All Exporters: It is not available for all types of exports, such as those who don’t manufacture the goods themselves.
Comparison Analysis: Which Scheme is More Beneficial for Exporters?
|
Aspect
|
Duty Drawback
|
Advance Authorization
|
|
Nature of Benefit
|
Refund of duties already paid.
|
Duty-free import of inputs.
|
|
Eligibility
|
Available to manufacturers and traders.
|
Available to manufacturers and merchant exporters.
|
|
Export Obligation
|
No export obligation.
|
Strict export obligation.
|
|
Import Duty Benefit
|
Does not offer duty-free imports.
|
Offers duty-free imports of inputs.
|
|
Cash Flow Impact
|
Provides a refund (indirect benefit).
|
Immediate cash flow savings (direct benefit).
|
|
Compliance Complexity
|
Simple and quick.
|
Complex, involves paperwork and obligations.
|
|
Market Competitiveness
|
Limited impact.
|
Major cost-saving, improves price competitiveness.
|
|
Time Frame
|
Faster turnaround for refunds.
|
Must meet export deadlines to avoid penalties.
|
Which Scheme is More Beneficial for Exporters?
- Duty Drawback is more beneficial for exporters who focus on finished goods or who want a simpler and faster process without the burden of export obligations. It's also better for traders/merchants who buy and sell finished products rather than engage in manufacturing.
- Advance Authorization is better suited for exporters involved in manufacturing who need to import raw materials and components regularly for production. It offers significant cost savings due to duty-free imports and can be very beneficial for large exporters who can meet the export obligations. However, the complexity and obligations might be a challenge for small exporters.
Conclusion:
The choice between Duty Drawback and Advance Authorization largely depends on the nature of the business. Manufacturers dealing with raw material inputs might find Advance Authorization more beneficial, while merchants or those with a simpler export model might prefer Duty Drawback for its simplicity and faster turnaround time.
***
9911796707
