2022 (8) TMI 153 - SC - GST

Direction for implementation of system for electronic (digital) generation of a Document Identification Number(DIN) for all communications sent by the state tax officers to taxpayers and other concerned persons - direction to the GST Council to consider and take a policy decision in respect of implementation of DIN system by all the states - direction to the Central Government/CBIC to introduce centralised DIN for the entire country - HELD THAT - From the averments in the petition, it appears that the State of Karnataka and the State of Kerala have implemented the system for the electronic (Digital) generation of a Document Identification Number (DIN) for all communications sent by the State Tax Officers to the taxpayers and other concerned persons. Put up the matter on 18.07.2022.

Summary

Issues: Implementation of electronic generation of Document Identification Number (DIN) by state tax officers, policy decision by GST Council, introduction of centralized DIN by Central Government/CBIC.

Analysis:
1. Implementation of DIN by State Tax Officers:
The petition under Article 32 seeks a writ of mandamus to implement a system for electronic generation of DIN by state tax officers for all communications with taxpayers. The petition highlights that the States of Karnataka and Kerala have already implemented this system, while other states have not. The grievance is directed towards the non-implementation by other states, indicating a lack of uniformity in the adoption of this system. The issue raises concerns regarding the efficiency and standardization of communication processes between state tax officers and taxpayers.

2. Policy Decision by GST Council:
Another relief sought in the petition is a writ of mandamus to the GST Council to consider and decide on the implementation of the DIN system by all states. This request emphasizes the need for a policy decision at the national level to ensure consistency and coherence in the adoption of the DIN system across all states. The involvement of the GST Council in this matter underscores the importance of a coordinated approach in implementing technological solutions for tax administration.

3. Introduction of Centralized DIN by Central Government/CBIC:
The petition also seeks a writ of mandamus for the Central Government/CBIC to introduce a centralized DIN system for the entire country. This request indicates the necessity for a uniform and centralized approach to the generation of DIN for tax-related communications nationwide. The call for a centralized system reflects the broader objective of streamlining administrative processes and enhancing the effectiveness of communication channels in the tax domain.

In conclusion, the judgment addresses the pressing need for the electronic generation of DIN by state tax officers, emphasizes the importance of a policy decision by the GST Council, and underscores the significance of a centralized DIN system introduced by the Central Government/CBIC. The case highlights the challenges posed by the lack of uniformity in implementing technological solutions in tax administration and underscores the imperative of harmonizing practices for efficient communication between tax authorities and taxpayers.