A Comparative Analysis of Scope of Total Income: Section 5 of Income-tax Act, 1961 and Clause 5 of Income Tax Bill, 2025

Clause 5 - Scope of total income

Income Tax Bill, 2025

Introduction

The scope of total income forms the foundation of income tax law in India, determining what income is taxable and for whom. This article analyzes the proposed changes in Clause 5 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025, comparing it with the existing Section 5 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, highlighting key modifications and their implications.

Objective and Purpose

Both provisions aim to define the scope of taxable income for residents and non-residents in India. The legislative intent appears to maintain the basic framework while introducing certain structural and linguistic refinements in the 2025 Bill to enhance clarity and address modern taxation needs.

Detailed Comparative Analysis

1. Structural Changes

• The 2025 Bill replaces "previous year" with "tax year," reflecting a more contemporary approach to temporal tax assessment
• The provision regarding "not ordinarily resident" has been moved from a proviso to the main clause 5(1)(c)
• The Explanations in the 1961 Act have been incorporated as main subsections in the 2025 Bill

2. Substantive Changes for Residents [Section 5(1)]

- Core principles remain unchanged regarding:

• Income received/deemed received in India
• Income accruing/arising or deemed to accrue/arise in India
• Income accruing/arising outside India

- Notable modification in treatment of foreign income for "not ordinarily resident" persons:

• 1961 Act: Addressed through proviso
• 2025 Bill: Integrated into main clause with direct reference to Section 6(13)

3. Non-Resident Taxation [Section 5(2)]

• Framework remains largely unchanged
• Linguistic refinements for better clarity
• Consistent use of terminology across sections

4. Prevention of Double Inclusion

• 1961 Act: Contained in Explanation 2
• 2025 Bill: Elevated to subsection 5(4)

Clearer articulation of the principle preventing double taxation of same income

5. Foreign Income Treatment

• 1961 Act: Addressed in Explanation 1
• 2025 Bill: Moved to subsection 5(3)

Clarifies treatment of foreign income in Indian balance sheets

Practical Implications

1. For Residents

• Clearer framework for "not ordinarily resident" taxation
• Better integration with other provisions
• Enhanced clarity on foreign income treatment

2. For Non-Residents

• Maintained consistency in tax treatment
• Improved clarity in language
• Better structured provisions

3. For Tax Administration

• Streamlined interpretation
• Reduced scope for litigation
• Better alignment with international taxation principles

Conclusion

The proposed Clause 5 represents an evolution rather than revolution in defining the scope of total income. While maintaining the fundamental principles, it introduces structural improvements and clarity enhancements that should facilitate better compliance and administration.

 

---

Full Text:

Clause 5

 

Dated: 24-2-2025