Treatment of losses incurred in the activity of owning and maintaining race horses : Clause 115 of Income Tax Bill, 2025 Vs. Section 74A of Income-tax Act, 1961

Submit your Comments

Contents

Clause 115 Set off and carry forward of losses from specified activity.

Income Tax Bill, 2025

Introduction

Clause 115 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025, and Section 74A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, both address the treatment of losses incurred in the activity of owning and maintaining race horses. These provisions are significant in the realm of taxation as they delineate how such losses can be set off and carried forward. The legislative intent behind these provisions is to provide a specific framework for taxpayers involved in the niche activity of horse racing, which is a distinct category under the broader head of "Income from other sources."

Objective and Purpose

The primary objective of Clause 115 and Section 74A is to regulate the financial treatment of losses incurred in the specified activity of horse racing. The legislative intent is to ensure that losses from such activities are not set off against income from other sources, thereby maintaining a clear demarcation between different income streams. This is particularly important given the unique nature of the horse racing industry, which involves significant financial risks and expenditures.

Historical Background

The inclusion of specific provisions for horse racing in the tax legislation can be traced back to the need for a structured approach to handle the financial peculiarities of this activity. Horse racing, being a high-stakes activity, often results in substantial financial losses, which necessitates a clear legislative framework to guide taxpayers on how these losses can be managed for tax purposes.

Detailed Analysis of Clause 115

Clause 115 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025, provides a comprehensive framework for the set-off and carry forward of losses from the specified activity of owning and maintaining race horses. It consists of several key components:

1. Restriction on Set-off Against Other Income: - Subsection (1) stipulates that any loss incurred in the specified activity during a tax year cannot be set off against income from other sources for that tax year. This provision ensures that the financial outcomes of horse racing activities are isolated from other income streams, thereby preventing cross-subsidization.

2. Carry Forward of Unabsorbed Losses: - Subsection (2) allows for the carry forward of unabsorbed losses from the specified activity to subsequent tax years. However, such losses can only be set off against income from the same specified activity, and only if the activity is continued by the assessee in the subsequent year.

3. Time Limit for Carry Forward: - Subsection (3) imposes a limitation on the carry forward period, restricting it to a maximum of four tax years immediately succeeding the year in which the loss was first computed. This provision encourages taxpayers to manage their financial affairs efficiently and limits the indefinite deferral of losses.

4. Definitions and Clarifications: - Subsection (4) provides definitions for key terms such as "income by way of stake money," "loss incurred by the assessee in the specified activity," "race horse," and "specified activity." These definitions are crucial for ensuring clarity and consistency in the application of the provision.

Comparison with Section 74A of Income-tax Act, 1961

Section 74A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, serves a similar purpose as Clause 115 but with some differences in structure and wording. A comparison of the two provisions reveals the following points:

1. Similarity in Purpose: - Both provisions aim to regulate the set-off and carry forward of losses from the activity of owning and maintaining race horses, ensuring that such losses are not set off against income from other sources.

2. Carry Forward Period: - Both Clause 115 and Section 74A restrict the carry forward of losses to a maximum of four years. This consistency reflects a common legislative intent to prevent the indefinite deferral of losses.

3. Definitions: - The definitions provided in both Clause 115 and Section 74A are largely similar, with minor variations in wording. Both provisions define key terms such as "income by way of stake money" and "loss incurred by the assessee," ensuring clarity in application.

4. Legislative Evolution: - Section 74A has undergone several amendments since its introduction, reflecting changes in policy and legislative priorities. Clause 115, being a part of a new bill, represents the latest iteration of legislative thinking on this subject.

Practical Implications

The provisions under Clause 115 and Section 74A have significant implications for stakeholders involved in the horse racing industry:

1. Tax Planning: - Taxpayers engaged in horse racing must carefully plan their financial affairs to manage losses within the four-year carry forward period. This requires strategic financial management and forecasting.

2. Compliance Requirements: - Compliance with these provisions necessitates meticulous record-keeping and documentation to substantiate claims of losses and ensure eligibility for carry forward.

3. Impact on Industry: - The restrictions on set-off and carry forward may influence investment decisions within the horse racing industry, as stakeholders must account for the potential financial implications of these tax provisions.

Comparative Analysis with Other Jurisdictions

While the provisions under Indian law are specific to the horse racing industry, similar frameworks exist in other jurisdictions, albeit with variations in detail and application.

A comparative analysis reveals:

1. International Approaches: - Some jurisdictions may allow broader set-off provisions, while others impose stricter limitations on the carry forward of losses. This reflects differing policy priorities and economic contexts.

2. Unique Features: - The specificity of the Indian provisions, focusing exclusively on horse racing, is a unique feature that underscores the cultural and economic significance of this activity in India.

Conclusion

Clause 115 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025, and Section 74A of the Income-tax Act, 1961, provide a structured framework for managing losses in the horse racing industry. These provisions reflect a balanced approach, allowing for the carry forward of losses while imposing reasonable restrictions to prevent abuse. As the legislative landscape evolves, these provisions may be subject to further refinement to address emerging challenges and opportunities in the industry.

Full Text:

Clause 115 Set off and carry forward of losses from specified activity.

Dated: 12-4-2025