Statutory provision offering tax deductions through savings and investments in specified financial products : Clause 123 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025 Vs. Section 80C of the Income Tax Act, 1961

Clause 123 Deduction for life insurance premia, deferred annuity, contributions to provident fund, etc.

Income Tax Bill, 2025

Introduction

Clause 123 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025, is a statutory provision that aims to offer deductions to individual taxpayers and Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs) in respect of payments made towards life insurance premia, deferred annuities, contributions to provident funds, and other specified investments. This clause is part of a broader legislative effort to provide tax relief and incentivize savings and investments among taxpayers. It mirrors the existing Section 80C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, which has been a cornerstone of tax deductions for Indian taxpayers for several decades. This commentary provides a detailed analysis of Clause 123 and compares it with Section 80C to understand their similarities, differences, and implications.

Objective and Purpose

The primary objective of Clause 123 is to encourage savings and investments by offering tax deductions for specified financial products. This aligns with the broader policy goal of promoting financial security and self-reliance among individuals and families. By allowing deductions for payments made towards life insurance, provident funds, and other savings instruments, the provision seeks to reduce the tax burden on taxpayers while encouraging long-term financial planning. Section 80C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, serves a similar purpose. Enacted to provide tax relief and promote savings, Section 80C has been instrumental in shaping the savings behavior of Indian taxpayers. It covers a wide range of investment options, from life insurance policies to equity-linked savings schemes, and offers deductions up to a specified limit. The section aims to balance immediate tax relief with long-term financial benefits for taxpayers.

Detailed Analysis

Clause 123 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025

Clause 123 allows deductions for individuals and HUFs for amounts paid or deposited in a tax year, up to a maximum of INR 1,50,000. The deductions cover payments towards life insurance premia, deferred annuities, contributions to provident funds, and other investments specified in Schedule XV of the Bill.

1. Scope and Coverage:

- Clause 123 applies to individuals and HUFs, similar to Section 80C. It covers a range of financial products, including life insurance and provident funds, which are traditional savings instruments in India.

- The inclusion of deferred annuities indicates a focus on long-term financial planning and retirement security.

2. Deduction Limit: - The maximum deduction limit under Clause 123 is INR 1,50,000, aligning with the existing limit u/s 80C. This consistency ensures that taxpayers do not face sudden changes in their tax planning strategies.

3. Conditions and Requirements: - The clause specifies that deductions are subject to conditions outlined in Schedule XV. While the exact conditions are not detailed in the document, they likely include requirements similar to those in Section 80C, such as minimum lock-in periods and eligible beneficiaries.

Detailed Analysis 

Section 80C of the Income Tax Act, 1961

Section 80C, provides a comprehensive framework for tax deductions on specified investments. It covers a wide range of financial products and has evolved over time to include new investment options.

1. Scope and Coverage:

- Section 80C applies to individuals and HUFs, offering deductions for payments made towards life insurance, provident funds, equity-linked savings schemes, and more.

- The section includes a diverse range of investment options, reflecting the evolving financial landscape and the need for flexibility in tax planning.

2. Deduction Limit: - The deduction limit u/s 80C is INR 1,50,000, consistent with Clause 123. This limit has been periodically revised to account for inflation and changing economic conditions.

3. Eligible Investments:

- Section 80C includes a detailed list of eligible investments, such as life insurance policies, deferred annuities, contributions to provident funds, and subscriptions to equity shares and debentures.

- The section also covers investments in housing, education, and pension funds, highlighting its comprehensive nature.

4. Conditions and Requirements: - The section outlines specific conditions for each type of investment, such as lock-in periods and eligible beneficiaries. For example, life insurance policies must cover the taxpayer or their immediate family members, and contributions to provident funds must comply with statutory requirements.

5. Compliance and Penalties: - Section 80C includes provisions for compliance and penalties. If taxpayers fail to meet the specified conditions, deductions may be disallowed, and the amounts deducted in previous years may be added back to their taxable income.

Comparative Analysis

1. Scope and Coverage: - Both Clause 123 and Section 80C apply to individuals and HUFs, covering similar financial products. However, Section 80C offers a broader range of investment options, reflecting its longer history and evolution.

2. Deduction Limit: - The deduction limit of INR 1,50,000 is consistent across both provisions, ensuring stability in tax planning for taxpayers.

3. Eligible Investments: - While both provisions cover life insurance, deferred annuities, and provident funds, Section 80C includes additional options such as equity-linked savings schemes and housing-related investments. This broader coverage u/s 80C offers greater flexibility for taxpayers in managing their investments.

4. Conditions and Requirements: - Both provisions impose conditions on eligible investments, though the specific requirements under Clause 123 are not detailed in the provided document. Section 80C's detailed conditions ensure compliance and safeguard against misuse.

5. Policy Objectives: - Both provisions aim to encourage savings and investments, contributing to financial security and economic stability. However, Section 80C's comprehensive coverage reflects a more mature policy framework, accommodating diverse investment needs.

Practical Implications

1. Tax Planning: - Both Clause 123 and Section 80C offer significant tax planning opportunities for individuals and HUFs. By investing in eligible financial products, taxpayers can reduce their taxable income and enhance their financial security.

2. Investment Behavior: - These provisions influence investment behavior by incentivizing long-term savings and financial planning. Taxpayers are encouraged to allocate funds to life insurance, provident funds, and other savings instruments, contributing to a culture of financial prudence.

3. Compliance Requirements: - Taxpayers must comply with the specified conditions to avail of deductions. This includes maintaining documentation, adhering to lock-in periods, and ensuring investments meet statutory requirements.

4. Economic Impact: - By promoting savings and investments, these provisions contribute to capital formation and economic growth. They support the development of financial markets and institutions, enhancing the overall economic stability of the country.

Conclusion

Clause 123 of the Income Tax Bill, 2025, and Section 80C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, are pivotal in shaping the tax landscape for Indian taxpayers. Both provisions aim to encourage savings and investments, offering tax relief and promoting financial security. While Clause 123 aligns closely with Section 80C in terms of scope and deduction limits, Section 80C's comprehensive coverage and detailed conditions reflect its established role in tax planning. As the financial landscape evolves, these provisions will continue to play a crucial role in guiding taxpayer behavior and supporting economic growth.

---

Full Text:

Clause 123 Deduction for life insurance premia, deferred annuity, contributions to provident fund, etc.

 

Dated: 14-4-2025