Scope of the "Point of difference" - Divergent views of the ...

Tribunal Declares Order in Insolvency Matter as Ministerial, Not Adjudicatory; Appeal Against It Not Maintainable.

June 15, 2022

Case Laws Insolvency and Bankruptcy AT

Scope of the "Point of difference" - Divergent views of the members of tribunal - matter referred to third member - appellant sight that more points to be included in the reference made to third member - this `Tribunal’ is of the earnest opinion that the said `impugned order’ cannot be termed by no stretch of imagination as `an Order’, in the teeth of culling out of `the point of difference’ (between the `Hon’ble Two Members of the Tribunal’) and formulating the same, is just a `Ministerial Act’ (`on Administrative Side’) of the `Tribunal’, without an entry upon any `Adjudicatory Process’. - No appeal is maintainable against the same - AT

View Source

← Previous Next →

Scope of the "Point of difference" - Divergent views of the ...

Tribunal Declares Order in Insolvency Matter as Ministerial, Not Adjudicatory; Appeal Against It Not Maintainable.

June 15, 2022

Case Laws Insolvency and Bankruptcy AT

You may also like:

Remand of the matter - the approach of the Tribunal is to abdicate its duty of deciding the matter on the merits or to retain the matter till the outcome of the pending...

Tribunal not deciding the matter itself and remanding it to the Assessing Officer - it is noticed that the approach of the Tribunal is to abdicate its duty of deciding...

Reference the matter to the larger bench of 3 members by the Single Member Bench - Even if the learned Member hearing this appeal found it difficult to accept the view...

The CESTAT dismissed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction, holding that Section 129A(1) of the Customs Act, 1962, explicitly excludes the Tribunal's jurisdiction over...

Impugned order suffers from non-application of mind, violation of principles of natural justice. Tribunal failed to consider grounds raised by petitioner for delay in...

Validity of order of the tribunal - The matter was heard by the Member (Judicial) of the Tribunal, however, the decision has been delivered by the Member (Technical) of...

The Tribunal thereafter could not have proceeded to examine the matter on merits after setting aside the order under Section 263 of the Act with reference to Section...

Rejection of central sale made by the assessee - once the Tribunal has recorded the finding that the documents, as required by it, was not placed by the assessee and no...

Tribunal dismissing the Appeal instead of disposing the matter on merits - It appears that on account of inadvertence, the senior chartered accountant engaged by the...

HC granted temporary stay on tax demand arising from appellate order based on Finance Ministry Circular regarding recovery guidelines pending formation of GST Appellate...

Scheme of faceless assessment - the time given to the petitioner to show cause was virtually of three days only - It is deemed appropriate that rather than this Bench,...

Proceedings in NCLT - part physical and part virtual hearing - infringement of Fundamental Rights - if the Tribunal wants to go for physical hearing of any particular...

HC quashed Tribunal's order regarding reopening of assessment based on alleged non-disclosure of unabsorbed investment allowance. The Tribunal erroneously concluded that...

The Appellate Tribunal examined the classification of services provided by the appellant to overseas educational institutions, determining whether they constituted...

Section 50C's multiplicative rate applicability was challenged. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal affirmed the Commissioner's order applying a factor of "1" to the...

Quick Updates: