Scope of the "Point of difference" - Divergent views of the ...

Case Laws Insolvency and Bankruptcy

June 15, 2022

Scope of the "Point of difference" - Divergent views of the members of tribunal - matter referred to third member - appellant sight that more points to be included in the reference made to third member - this `Tribunal’ is of the earnest opinion that the said `impugned order’ cannot be termed by no stretch of imagination as `an Order’, in the teeth of culling out of `the point of difference’ (between the `Hon’ble Two Members of the Tribunal’) and formulating the same, is just a `Ministerial Act’ (`on Administrative Side’) of the `Tribunal’, without an entry upon any `Adjudicatory Process’. - No appeal is maintainable against the same - AT

View Source

← Previous Next →

Scope of the "Point of difference" - Divergent views of the ...

Case Laws Insolvency and Bankruptcy

June 15, 2022

You may also like:

Maintainability of Reference to Third to member - Difference of opinion - Classification of services - internet telecommunication service or not - The decisions, on...

Reference the matter to the larger bench of 3 members by the Single Member Bench - Even if the learned Member hearing this appeal found it difficult to accept the view...

Demand - Revenue neutral exercise - Whether the pre-deposit is to be waived on the basis of revenue neutrality assessed by Member (Judicial) or pre-deposit should be...

Scheme of faceless assessment - the time given to the petitioner to show cause was virtually of three days only - It is deemed appropriate that rather than this Bench,...

The coordinate benches of the Tribunal have consistently decided the issue of availment of CENVAT credit by insurance companies on invoices issued by dealers or...

Extension of tenure of the existing Technical Member of the West Bengal Taxation Tribunal - The Administrative Member of the Tribunal has continued by virtue of interim...

Manner of disposal of application for advance ruling under Income Tax Act, 1961 - If the Members of a Board for Advance Rulings have differing opinions on any point, it...

Addition of bogus sales - difference in opinion between learned Members constituting the bench - The appellate tribunal (Third Member) addressed the dispute arising from...

Demand of service tax - Management consultancy service - activity of running, operating and managing the entire hotel business - As both Members have a difference of...

Constitution of the GST Appellate Tribunal - Section 110(1)(b)(iii) of the CGST Act which states that a Member of the Indian Legal Services, who has held a post not less...

The Appellate Tribunal addressed the claim of deduction u/s 32AD for additional investment allowance on an investment made in the financial year 2015-16. The issue arose...

Validity of order of the tribunal - The matter was heard by the Member (Judicial) of the Tribunal, however, the decision has been delivered by the Member (Technical) of...

Violation of principles of natural justice occurred as petitioner's contentions were not considered - mismatch between petitioner's GSTR 3B returns and auto-populated...

Maintainability of appeal before tribunal - Seizure of goods - Section 110(A) - Two member bench disagrees with the decision of larger bench - matter referred to the...

Principle or the doctrine of mutuality - Tribunal for the earlier years, has held that even if there are non-permanent members, non-life members, temporary or honorary...

Quick Updates: