Bench Reconstitution and Order Pronouncement - Whether an order ...

Case Laws Insolvency and Bankruptcy

April 22, 2024

Bench Reconstitution and Order Pronouncement - Whether an order reserved by a bench could be pronounced by a reconstituted bench without considering a subsequent application that called for a re-hearing based on new developments. - According to Tribunal directives, a judgment reserved should ideally be pronounced by the same bench unless re-hearing is warranted by substantial subsequent developments. Ultimately, the Appellate Tribunal set aside the order pronounced by the reconstituted bench and remanded the case back to the regular bench for a fresh hearing. It emphasized that the judicial process must consider all relevant developments to ensure fair adjudication.

View Source

← Previous Next →

Bench Reconstitution and Order Pronouncement - Whether an order ...

Case Laws Insolvency and Bankruptcy

April 22, 2024

You may also like:

Scope of pronouncing of judgement - The law does not permit that the case is heard by one entity and the order is pronounced by another who has not heard the case at all....

Majority order of the Tribunal - It is axiomatic that if at the time of pronouncement all the members of the Bench are not available, on account of any of them having...

Levy of Entry Tax - Motive of the appellant behind litigation - The order of the writ Court overlooks the fact that the view/stand taken by the petitioner, insofar as...

Referring matter to larger bench - It is not open to the Referral Bench to appreciate the judgment rendered by the earlier Bench as if sitting in appeal to hold that the...

Maintainability of appeal before tribunal - Seizure of goods - Section 110(A) - Two member bench disagrees with the decision of larger bench - matter referred to the...

Pursuant to sections 109(1), (3) and (4) of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, the Ministry of Finance constituted the Goods and Services Tax Appellate...

Appellate jurisdiction of ITAT - ITAT Kolkata or ITAT Indore - approaching the wrong appellate jurisdiction - President, ITAT, has no power to transfer appeal/s between...

Supremacy of decision division bench of a non-jurisdictional High Court and a single judge bench of a non-jurisdictional High Court - judicial hierarchy - Applicability...

Binding Judgement of Lager Bench / Majority decision - strength of the Bench - In view of Article 145(5) of the Constitution of India concurrence of a majority of the...

Scheme of faceless assessment - the time given to the petitioner to show cause was virtually of three days only - It is deemed appropriate that rather than this Bench,...

Reference the matter to the larger bench of 3 members by the Single Member Bench - Even if the learned Member hearing this appeal found it difficult to accept the view...

Criminal proceedings involving allegations of fraudulent activities in an IPO were challenged. The validity hinged on whether a Single Judge or Division Bench should...

Detention order challenged due to non-supply of relevant WhatsApp chats, which were part of the evidence relied upon by the detaining authority. The High Court Division...

The Supreme Court addressed the issue of the maintainability of a complaint u/s Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 due to an improper grant of bail by a Bench not...

The Tribunal allowed the appeal filed by the appellant and set aside the impugned order disallowing CENVAT credit taken on input services used in BTS (Base Transceiver...

Quick Updates: