Royalty's nature - not a tax but contractual consideration paid ...

Royalty isn't tax but contractual pay for mineral rights. States can tax mineral lands via Entry 50, but Entry 50 subtracts from Entry 49's scope.

Case Laws Indian Laws

July 30, 2024

Royalty's nature - not a tax but contractual consideration paid by mining lessee to lessor for enjoying mineral rights. Entry 50 List II empowers State legislatures to tax mineral rights. Parliament can impose limitations on this field under law relating to mineral development, but MMDR Act doesn't contain such limitations. Entry 50 doesn't constitute exception to Sundararamier case principles. States can tax mineral-bearing lands under Entry 49 List II, using mineral value/produce as measure. Entry 50 being specific, subtracts mining lands from Entry 49's scope. Relevant SC decisions overruled to extent of present observations. Dissenting view - royalty is tax under Article 366(28); Entry 50 subject to Entry 54 List I limitations like MMDR Act provisions, departing from Sundararamier principles for Entry 50; Entry 50 excludes Entry 49's application to mineral lands.

View Source

← Previous Next →

Royalty's nature - not a tax but contractual consideration paid ...

Royalty isn't tax but contractual pay for mineral rights. States can tax mineral lands via Entry 50, but Entry 50 subtracts from Entry 49's scope.

Case Laws Indian Laws

July 30, 2024

You may also like:

Levy of GST - lease of land for mining - ‘licensing services for the right to use minerals including its exploration and evaluation - Both these amounts are paid in...

Royalty paid by a mineral concession holder for mining concessions granted by the State is subject to GST levy. The constitutional validity of notifications issued by...

Classification - Grant of mining lease for extracting Mineral called “BLACKTRAP” - payment of rent/royalty is for license given to extract minerals and the amount of...

The Supreme Court upheld the validity of the Explanations to Rule 38 of the Mineral (Other than Atomic and Hydrocarbons Energy Minerals) Concession Rules, 2016 and Rule...

This case deals with the taxability of compensation paid to landowners for land acquisition. The court held that u/s 96 of the Right to Fair Compensation and...

Income taxable in India - royalty receipts - copyright - Light to broadcast “Live events” - when the agreements clearly bifurcate the consideration paid towards Live and...

The Court held that the demand for levy/fee/royalty on advertisements made without legislative sanction is violative of Article 265 of the Constitution. The imposition...

Levy of GST - reverse charge mechanism - royalty paid/dead rent on account of mining rights - The activity of assignment of rights to use natural resources is treated as...

Levy of GST - minerals on which already royalty has been paid - the very issue as to whether GST would be chargeable on minerals on which already royalty has been paid...

Disallowance u/s 43B - nomination charges paid to the State Government at the rate of 10% of the turnover of granite blocks - It is simply a contractual payment of lease...

Classification of services - Leasing - Royalty - exploration of natural resources - This activity of payment of lease charge/ dead rent/ royalty is towards the supply of...

Levy of Service Tax and / or GST on royalty and District Mineral Fund (DMF) - royalty for grant of mining lease - royalty has been considered to be a tax or profit...

Refusal to honour the liability of paying the service tax (on the part of LIC) - Renting of immovable property to LIC - It is to be borne in mind that the LIC being an...

Gains arising on sale of Agricultural land – Assessee might not have paid agricultural income-tax but is paying land revenue and village records clearly showed the land...

Taxability of shipping income - Shipping income as dealt by Article-8 states that profits derived by an enterprise of a contracting state by operation of ships in...

Quick Updates: