The Appellate Tribunal examined the case concerning the ...

Duty assessment dispute: Tribunal orders review of aluminium scrap import valuation after flawed appeal process.

Case Laws Customs

November 8, 2024

The Appellate Tribunal examined the case concerning the valuation of imported aluminium scrap and the re-determination of its assessable value. The respondent had self-assessed the duty, but the Assessing Officer (AO) rejected the transaction value, citing discrepancies with contemporary import data available in the National Import Database (NIDB). However, the Commissioner (Appeals) failed to consider the reasons provided by the AO for re-determining the assessable value. Instead, the Commissioner addressed issues not considered by the AO in the speaking order and did not examine the relevant Bills of Entry that formed the basis for rejecting the transaction value. Consequently, the Appellate Tribunal held that the order passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) cannot be sustained and directed the Commissioner to pass a fresh order within four months, considering the AO's reasons for re-determining the assessable value.

View Source

← Previous Next →

The Appellate Tribunal examined the case concerning the ...

Duty assessment dispute: Tribunal orders review of aluminium scrap import valuation after flawed appeal process.

Case Laws Customs

November 8, 2024

You may also like:

Valuation of imported goods - undervaluation of Zinc and aluminium scrap imported - The circular only provides for average price difference between the price of prime...

Provisional release of imported goods (apples) - The dispute centers on the valuation of the imported apples.

Goods classified as Aluminium Scrap Tassel under CTH 76020010 instead of Coils of Aluminium Wire under 76051100. Chartered Engineer Certificate confirmed goods not in...

Mis-declaration of imported goods - ‘Aluminium Alloy Ingots’ or ‘Aluminium Scrap Throb’ - the goods stands described in the various import documents as “Aluminium Scrap...

Valuation of imported goods - Aluminium Scrap - rejection of declared value - These imports were made subsequent to the imports made in earlier order therefore, the...

Review of Order after gap of 13 years - delay can be condoned or not - There is a period of one year provided as per the Act, 2003 for seeking review of any order passed...

Valuation of imported goods - aluminium scrap - enhancement of value - The Tribunal referred to a previous decision where it was asserted that the appellant had agreed...

Valuation of imported goods - Aluminium Scrap - rejection of transaction value - procedure contemplated under Rule 12 of the valuation rules not followed - Commissioner...

Valuation of imported goods - inclusion of royalty in the invoice value - The Appellate Tribunal finds that the direction to modify the order and include royalty in the...

The case pertains to the valuation of imported porcelain vitrified tiles. The key points are: The assessment attained finality, but the appellant has the legal right to...

Classification of imported goods - Imports aluminium shelving for Mushroom - The Appellate Tribunal ruled in favor of the appellant. They determined that the imported...

Judgment of the Larger Bench of Tribunal on Aluminum dross and skimming – reg. - Order-Instruction

Validity of Re-determination of Value - Goods have already been cleared from the port of import after examination and enhancement of value - The Appellate Tribunal found...

The Tribunal held that the assessment order passed by the Assessing Officer was barred by limitation and quashed it. As per Section 144C(13) read with Section 143(3),...

Intention and Compliance with Notification Conditions - Import and sale of Motor Spirit, commonly known as Petrol - Availing of a concessional rate of Countervailing...

Quick Updates: