HC reduced penalty from Rs. 17.10 lakhs to Rs. 10,000 for a SEZ ...

SEZ Unit's Penalty Slashed After Weather Damage Led to NFE Shortfall; Later Achieved Compliance Under Rule 54(2)

February 7, 2025

Case Laws     Customs     HC

HC reduced penalty from Rs. 17.10 lakhs to Rs. 10,000 for a SEZ unit's failure to achieve positive Net Foreign Exchange Earnings (NFE) in 2008-09. The unit's inability was attributed to severe weather conditions causing damage to export goods. The court considered that the unit subsequently achieved positive NFE in 2011-12 and maintained compliance over the five-year block period (2005-06 to 2009-10). Under Rule 54(2) of SEZ Rules and FTDR Act, the court deemed the original penalty excessive, noting the temporary nature of the breach and valid explanations provided. The token penalty reflects a proportionate response to the technical violation while acknowledging the unit's overall compliance and mitigating circumstances.

View Source