HC determined that Revenue's contradictory stance regarding ...

Revenue Cannot Use Same Advisory Letter as Both Non-Statutory and Binding to Deny BCCI's Tax Exemptions Under Section 11

February 19, 2025

Case Laws Income Tax HC

HC determined that Revenue's contradictory stance regarding BCCI's registration status was legally untenable. While Revenue argued the communication dated 28 December 2009 was merely advisory and non-statutory to challenge appeal maintainability before ITAT, it simultaneously used the same communication to effectively cancel BCCI's registration and deny tax exemptions under Section 11 of IT Act. Court held that Revenue cannot treat the communication as non-statutory to defeat appeal rights while using it to adversely affect assessee's substantive rights. The decision emphasizes that vital matters like registration cancellation or exemption denial must be based on proper statutory orders, not mere advisory communications.

View Source

← Previous Next →

HC determined that Revenue's contradictory stance regarding ...

Revenue Cannot Use Same Advisory Letter as Both Non-Statutory and Binding to Deny BCCI's Tax Exemptions Under Section 11

February 19, 2025

Case Laws Income Tax HC

You may also like:

The writ petition challenging notices u/ss 13(2) and 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act, 2002, including alleged arbitrary action for non-compliance with a letter of arrangement...

C.B.E. & C. Advisory on Customs related matters on introduction of Goods and Services Tax regime

The High Court examined the issue of denial of operation and maintenance benefits u/s 26 of the SEZ Act for the intervening period from 01.04.2015 to 08.05.2016. It...

Franchise service or Business Support services - demand of service tax on Central Rights Income - Revenue Sharing - BCCI is not commercial organization and only...

Double taxation of income in the hands of BCCI and Assessee, as the member of AOP - it will be open to the AO of the appellant to reopen the case of the appellant and to...

Disallowance of commission expenses - Non-service of letters to the buyers or non-compliance of the letters by the buyers does not show that the payment of commission...

Non filling of Electronic appeal - appeals filed by the assessee filled physically - the revenue can not take the benefit of non functioning/ malfunctioning of its...

Validity of SCN and audit notes issued - mandatory pre-show cause notice Consultation- A master circular issued by the department is binding upon its officers. The...

Exemption u/s 11 - subsidy received from BCCI - BARODA CRICKET ASSOCIATION - Charitable activities u/s 2(15) - we are not convinced with the case put up by the Revenue....

Classification of services - Export of service or not - Management, Business Consultancy Services or Real Estate Agent service - appellant is engaged in providing...

Scope and validity of opinion of the Advisory Board - the nature of opinion given by the Advisory Board is neither judicial nor quasi judicial; that it would be...

The decisions of the Hon’ble non-jurisdictional High Court have no relevance in the present context. It is also elementary in law that the mere pendency of the appeal,...

The High Court held that after the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal's order, the tax authorities are bound to refund the amount to the petitioner with interest, without...

TP adjustment commission on letter of credit - international transaction or not? - CIT (A) appreciated the difference between corporate guarantee and Letter of Comfort....

Arbitration agreement - group company - binding of the agreement on the subsidiary company - A non-signatory can be bound by an arbitration agreement on the basis of the...

Quick Updates: