ITAT resolved a critical tax interpretation issue regarding ...

Tax Surcharge for Private Discretionary Trusts Calculated Using Graduated Rates, Not Uniform Maximum Marginal Rate

April 12, 2025

Case Laws Income Tax AT

ITAT resolved a critical tax interpretation issue regarding surcharge computation for private discretionary trusts. The tribunal determined that surcharge should be calculated based on specific slab rates prescribed in the Finance Act, not automatically at the highest 37% rate for incomes above Rs. 5 crores. The ruling emphasized a harmonious interpretation of statutory provisions, rejecting the revenue department's argument for uniform maximum marginal rate application. The decision ensures that different surcharge rates remain meaningful and prevents discriminatory taxation. Ultimately, the tribunal decided in favor of the assessee, mandating that surcharge computation for private discretionary trusts must follow the graduated rates outlined in the Finance Act's first schedule.

View Source

← Previous Next →

ITAT resolved a critical tax interpretation issue regarding ...

Tax Surcharge for Private Discretionary Trusts Calculated Using Graduated Rates, Not Uniform Maximum Marginal Rate

April 12, 2025

Case Laws Income Tax AT

You may also like:

Discretionary trust liable to pay tax at maximum marginal rate, including highest slab rate of income tax and surcharge applicable to individuals. Section 2(29C)...

Status of a private discretionary trust - AOP OR Individual - The Ld. CIT(A) has interpreted the meaning of AOP - the subsequent amendment by explanation to section...

ITAT determined that a registered charitable trust's income should be taxed at normal rates rather than maximum marginal rates, despite undefined trustee shares. While...

The appellant trust claimed to be formed for public charitable activities and registered under the Rajasthan Public Trust Act 1959, regularly filing its income tax...

Levy of Surcharge and cess - to be computed over the rate of tax as per DTAA or not - Article 12 read with Article 2 of the tax treaty makes it clear that the rate of...

Co-operative Societies - Rate of Income Tax - For normal provision same rate of tax and surcharge as applicable will continue and for computation of tax under sec 115BAD...

Assessment of trust as Association of Persons (AOP) - family trust - rate of tax - maximum marginal rate or slab rates - Assessee family trust has only income from other...

Assessment of trust/AOP - trust to be assessed in the status of AOP - religious trusts / deity - Levying tax at the maximum marginal rate instead of rates applicable to...

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) examined the taxability of income from a discretionary trust u/s 164(1) read with clause (ii) of Explanation 1 to Section 164 of...

Minimum alternate Tax (MAT) - Tax credit u/s 115JAA - surcharge and cess - Revenue (CPC) has admittedly applied surcharge and education cess on a tax credit u/s. 115JAA...

This summary concerns an appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal regarding violations of Sections 11 to 13 of the Income Tax Act by a trust. The key points are:...

The assessee, a trust, claimed to be taxed at the same rate applicable to its beneficiary u/s 115BAA. However, this claim was dismissed as the assessee was not treated...

RATES OF INCOME-TAX for the PY 2022-23 i.e. AY 2023-24 [As per previous year Budget and comparison with Budget 2023 proposals] - Notes In the new tax regime increase the...

The assessee, a US citizen residing permanently in India, claimed that the tax rates specified in the India-USA DTAA include surcharge, surtax, and education cess would...

The trust is discretionary trust. Hence, it is liable to be assessed as per the provisions of Sec.164(1) at maximum marginal rate.

Quick Updates: