2002 (4) TMI 684 - AT - Central Excise

Issues Involved:
1. Eligibility for exemption under Notification No. 136/94 for the items: refrigerated truck, diesel generator sets, mobile refrigeration unit, cold storage unit, transformer, and air-conditioning units.

Detailed Analysis:

1. Eligibility for Exemption under Notification No. 136/94:
The primary issue is whether the items in dispute qualify for exemption from excise duty under Notification No. 136/94, which provides exemptions for goods used in connection with the production, manufacture, or packaging of specified materials by Export Oriented Units (EOUs).

Arguments by Commissioner (Appeals):
The Commissioner (Appeals) allowed the benefit of the exemption, stating that the items in question are essential for the production, packaging, and export of flowers, which are perishable and require a refrigerated atmosphere to maintain freshness. The Commissioner referenced the Supreme Court's interpretation in the J.K. Cotton Spinning & Weaving Mills case, which broadened the scope of "in the manufacture" to include all processes directly related to production. The Commissioner concluded that the goods in question, such as air conditioners, transformers, and diesel generator sets, are necessary for maintaining the refrigerated conditions required for exporting cut flowers.

Revenue's Contention:
The Revenue argued that the transformer does not fall under the specified items in Annexure I of the notification and thus should not be granted the exemption. They asserted that the notification should be strictly interpreted to include only those items explicitly listed. The Revenue also contested the applicability of the Supreme Court's ruling in the J.K. Cotton case to this situation.

Respondents' Argument:
The respondents, representing floriculture units, argued that the refrigerated truck, diesel generator sets, and other equipment are crucial for maintaining the required conditions for exporting cut flowers. They emphasized that the transformer is essential for operating the green house and maintaining the necessary atmospheric conditions. They also cited a Board Circular which stated that the green house itself could be considered equipment under the notification.

Tribunal's Majority Decision:
The majority of the Tribunal upheld the Commissioner (Appeals)'s decision, agreeing that the items in question are essential for the production and export of cut flowers. They emphasized that the term "in connection with the production or manufacture or packaging" should be interpreted broadly to include all necessary equipment for maintaining the conditions required for exporting the goods.

2. Specific Items Considered:
- Transformer: The Tribunal found that the transformer is essential for providing power to the green house and other equipment, thus qualifying it for exemption under the notification.
- Refrigerated Truck and Diesel Generator Sets: These items are necessary for transporting and maintaining the cut flowers at the required temperature until they reach the overseas market, making them eligible for the exemption.
- Mobile Refrigeration Unit and Cold Storage Unit: These units are crucial for maintaining the temperature of the cut flowers during transit and storage, thus qualifying for the exemption.
- Air-conditioning Units: The Tribunal agreed that air-conditioning units are necessary for maintaining the required temperature for the flowers, thus eligible for the exemption.

Separate Judgments:
- Member (Technical): Disagreed with the majority, arguing that the items in question should not be considered as green house equipment or its accessories as per the strict interpretation of the notification. He contended that items like the transformer and refrigerated truck are not used within the green house and thus do not qualify for the exemption.
- Third Member (Technical): Agreed with the majority, emphasizing the broad interpretation of the notification and the essentiality of the items for the production and export of cut flowers.

Conclusion:
In terms of the majority order, the impugned order passed by the Commissioner (Appeals) is confirmed, and the Revenue appeals are rejected. The Tribunal concluded that the items in dispute are essential for the production, packaging, and export of cut flowers and thus qualify for exemption under Notification No. 136/94.

← Previous Next →