1991 (3) TMI 361 - HC - VAT and Sales Tax

Summary

Issues: Whether the transactions constitute inter-State sale of goods

In the judgment delivered by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh, the Court analyzed the findings of the Tribunal regarding the nature of transactions involving a company with 22 depots in various states and wholesale dealers. The wholesalers registered their requirements with the depots to secure rate commitments, and the company dispatched goods to the depots at regular intervals. The goods were then sold to wholesale buyers who approached the depots for purchase. The Court considered sample transactions, such as one involving M/s. Lakshminarayana Stores in Bangalore, to determine the appropriateness of the conclusions drawn by the revisional authority. The Court noted that the movement of goods from the factory to the depots did not have a direct nexus with specific indents placed by wholesalers. The Court agreed with the Sales Tax Appellate Tribunal's reasoning that the transactions did not constitute inter-State sales of goods. Consequently, the tax revision case was dismissed, and the petition was also dismissed.