9911796707
|
Home
Forgot password New User/ Regiser ⇒ Register to get Live Demo
1961 (7) TMI 71 - HC - VAT and Sales Tax
Issues:
1. Whether the proceeds from the sales of dry cattle are to be included in the turnover of a firm liable to sales tax. 2. Whether the firm is considered a dealer in dry cattle as part of its business for the purpose of sales tax assessment. Analysis: Issue 1: The tax revision cases involved the question of whether the proceeds from the sales of dry cattle by a dairy firm should be counted as part of the turnover liable to sales tax. The Sales Tax Authorities had included the sale proceeds in the turnover based on a prior decision of the Court. The firm contended that the sales were occasional and necessary to avoid deterioration of the stock, not constituting a dealing in cattle as their primary business was dairy products. However, the Court held that all sales of a dealer in the course of business attract taxation under the Sales Tax Act, irrespective of the nature of the goods sold. Issue 2: The key issue was whether the firm could be considered a dealer in dry cattle as part of its business. The firm argued that being registered only for dairy products, they should not be considered a dealer in cattle as the sales were occasional and not the primary business activity. The Court examined various precedents and emphasized that the volume, regularity, and nature of transactions determine if one is a dealer in a particular commodity. The Court noted that the firm regularly sold unserviceable cows, generating significant proceeds annually, indicating a systematic business activity beyond mere casual transactions. Relying on precedents, the Court concluded that the firm's sales of dry cattle constituted business activities, making them liable to taxation under the Sales Tax Act. In conclusion, the Court dismissed the revision petitions, affirming that the firm's sales of dry cattle were part of its business activities, thus making them a dealer liable to sales tax. The Court reiterated that the nature and volume of transactions determine if one is a dealer in a particular commodity, emphasizing that all sales in the course of business attract taxation under the Sales Tax Act.
|
