9911796707
|
Home
Issues: Valuation of closing stock for estate duty purposes.
In this case, the main issue before the court was the valuation of the closing stock of a firm for estate duty purposes. The court had to determine whether the Tribunal was correct in holding that the value of the closing stock should be enhanced to the extent of the market price obtainable in retail sales. The deceased, Shri K. P. Chackunny, was a partner in the firm, and his widow, Smt. Mary Chacko, was liable to pay estate duty based on the valuation of the closing stock of the firm, Messrs. Popular Automobiles. The firm valued its closing stock at cost, but for estate duty purposes, the market value of the assets at the time of the deceased's death needed to be considered. The firm purchased goods in large quantities and received a special discount of 12.5%. The Assistant Controller of Estate Duty added this special discount to the closing stock value shown in the estate duty return to determine the share liable for estate duty. The court noted that the assessing authority had only considered the special discount aspect and failed to consider other statutory provisions, specifically Section 36 of the Estate Duty Act, 1953, which dictates how property should be valued for estate duty purposes. Despite the appellate authorities' decisions, the court emphasized the importance of considering all relevant aspects of valuation. The court found that the valuation of the closing stock should include the profit element, given that the firm earned a 12.5% profit on its sales. The court concluded that the question should be answered in favor of the Revenue, indicating that the closing stock's value should be increased by 12.5% for estate duty calculation purposes. As a result of the judgment, a copy was to be sent to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Cochin Bench, for further action in line with the court's decision.
|
