2017 (7) TMI 49 - AT - Central Excise

Classification of goods - whether the goods described viz. Switches relays fuses plugs lamps in para 14 of the adjudication order belong to the Tariff heading 87.08 or 85.36/85.39 or any other entry for levy of duty under Third Schedule to the Central Excise Act 1944? - Held that - In the absence of detailed examination in the manner above in the adjudication order it is very difficult on the part of the Tribunal to go into the grass root for classification. Description of goods in tariff entry may depend on the technical literature as well as various technicalities of the goods which learned adjudicating authority shall have advantage to examine better - to grant fair opportunity of hearing to both sides to place their case before adjudicating authority for his determination of classification and decide leviability matters are remanded to the Ld. Authority who shall grant hearing and test each goods covered by the show-cause notice for appropriate classification and levy of excise duty if any leviable - appeal allowed by way of remand.

Issues involved: Classification of goods under Tariff headings 87.08, 85.36/85.39, or any other entry for levy of duty under the Third Schedule to the Central Excise Act, 1944; Determination of nature and character of goods for appropriate classification and levy of excise duty; Leviability of penalty.

Analysis:

1. The appellants raised a preliminary issue regarding the classification of goods described in the adjudication order under specific tariff headings. It was contended that the adjudicating authority did not provide reasoning or conduct testing to determine the appropriate classification, which is essential for levying duty under the Central Excise Act, 1944. The lack of proper analysis based on the nature and composition of the goods led to an inconclusive decision on the classification, contrary to legal requirements.

2. The grounds of appeal highlighted the importance of understanding the description of tariff entries 87.08 or 87.14 for the proper classification of the goods in question. The absence of a detailed examination by the adjudicating authority regarding the character and nature of the goods raised concerns about the validity of the classification decision.

3. It was emphasized that the classification of goods under the Third Schedule of the Central Excise Act, 1944, is crucial for determining the levy of duty. Both parties agreed that goods not covered by the Third Schedule are not leviable to duty. The appellants, engaged in manufacturing and trading activities, sought a thorough scrutiny of the classification to establish the correct levy of duty.

4. The Tribunal highlighted the necessity for the adjudicating authority to independently determine the nature and character of the goods based on statutory provisions and judicial pronouncements. A comprehensive analysis, considering various tests prescribed by law, was deemed essential to arrive at a reasoned and speaking order amenable to judicial scrutiny.

5. Due to the lack of detailed examination in the adjudication order, the Tribunal remanded the matter to the adjudicating authority for a thorough assessment of each goods covered by the show-cause notice. The authority was directed to conduct a detailed examination, grant a fair opportunity of hearing to both sides, and pass an appropriate order within the legal framework by a specified deadline.

6. The issue of the penalty's leviability was deferred for further examination by the adjudicating authority, emphasizing the need for a detailed assessment of the penalty's ingredients. The authority was instructed to grant a reasonable opportunity of hearing to the appellants and make a decision on the penalty after recording their defense plea.

7. Ultimately, the appeals were disposed of based on the outlined directions for the adjudicating authority to re-examine the classification of goods, determine the levy of excise duty, and address the penalty issue after due consideration of all relevant factors.

← Previous Next →